Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Tender offer rules
Tender offer rules
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
How the Williams Act rules work: who is covered, Schedule TO, the minimum time periods, withdrawal rights, all-holders and best-price, proration, the target’s response, and the limits on trading around an offer.
The rules
- Who’s covered: Section 14(d) and Regulation 14D apply to a third-party offer for registered equity that would leave the bidder with more than 5% of the class. Section 14(e) and Regulation 14E apply to every tender offer, including debt and unregistered securities. Rule 13e-4 covers an issuer or its affiliate buying its own equity. “Tender offer” isn’t defined; courts weigh factors such as wide solicitation, a premium, firm terms, a time limit and pressure to sell (the Wellman factors).
- Starting the offer: an offer commences at 12:01 a.m. on the day the bidder first gives holders the means to tender. The bidder files Schedule TO as soon as practicable that day, sends it to the target, notifies the exchanges and disseminates the terms. Earlier written communications are filed under cover of Schedule TO by the date of use, with a legend (Rule 14d-2(b)). Rule 14e-8 bars announcing an offer without the intent or means to complete it.
- Timing (Rule 14e-1): an offer stays open at least 20 business days, and at least 10 business days after a change in price, percentage sought or dealer’s fee (buying up to another 2% of the class doesn’t count). SEC staff generally expect 5 business days after other material changes, such as waiving a minimum condition. A business day excludes weekends and federal holidays and runs 12:01 a.m. to midnight Eastern, and the start date counts as day one. An extension must be announced by 9:00 a.m. Eastern on the next business day (or the exchange opening, if earlier). Payment or return of shares must be prompt.
- Withdrawal rights: holders can withdraw any time while the offer is open (Rule 14d-7), and under Section 14(d)(5) after 60 days from commencement if the shares haven’t been accepted. For an issuer offer the second date is 40 business days (Rule 13e-4(f)(2)).
- All-holders and best-price (Rule 14d-10): the offer must be open to all holders of the class, and each must get the highest consideration paid to any other holder in the offer. If two forms of payment are offered, holders get an equal right to elect. Raising the price benefits everyone, even shares already tendered (Section 14(d)(7)). Employment and severance pay isn’t price if it’s for services and isn’t based on shares tendered. Approval by independent directors is a non-exclusive safe harbor that secures this result, not a requirement.
- Proration: if a partial offer is oversubscribed, the bidder buys pro rata from shares tendered during the whole offer (Rule 14d-8), not only the first 10 days named in Section 14(d)(6). An issuer may first accept odd lots from holders of fewer than 100 shares who tender everything (Rule 13e-4(f)(3)).
- Subsequent offering period (Rule 14d-11): after an initial period of at least 20 business days, a bidder in an offer for all shares may add at least 3 business days to scoop up stragglers. It must announce results by 9:00 a.m. Eastern the next business day, pay for shares already tendered, and offer the same form and amount. No withdrawal rights are required.
- Target’s response: within 10 business days of the offer’s first publication, the target must tell holders that it recommends accepting or rejecting, expresses no opinion, or can’t take a position, with reasons (Rule 14e-2). Any recommendation goes on Schedule 14D-9 as soon as practicable on the day first sent (Rule 14d-9). A short “stop, look and listen” letter can ask holders to wait.
- Trading limits: Rule 14e-3 bars trading on material nonpublic information about an offer once substantial steps have been taken, with no need to show a breach of duty, and bars tipping. Rule 14e-4 requires a net long position at tender and at the end of proration in a partial offer (no short tendering). Rule 14e-5 bars the bidder, its dealer-manager and success-fee advisers from buying outside the offer from announcement to expiration. Rule 13e-1 makes a target file a statement before buying its own stock during a third-party offer. Rule 13e-4(f)(6) bars an issuer from buying outside its own offer for 10 business days after it ends.
- Exceptions you may meet: an SEC staff order of 16 Apr 2026 lets qualifying offers run 10 business days: all cash at a fixed price, no competing offer, not going-private, and either a negotiated third-party offer for all shares or an issuer offer for less than all. An order of 30 Jun 2026 allows 5 business days for qualifying non-convertible debt offers. Rule 14e-1 itself still says 20. Cross-border offers get relief where U.S. holders own 10% or less (Tier I) or 40% or less (Tier II).
Formulas
- Proration factor: Shares the bidder will buy ÷ shares validly tendered
- Shares bought from a holder: Shares that holder tendered × proration factor
Common traps
- Regulation 14E reaches all tender offers. Regulation 14D needs registered equity and a stake above 5%.
- A price change needs at least 10 business days left after the notice, not a fresh 20.
- Withdrawal dates differ: 60 days from commencement for third-party offers, 40 business days for issuer offers.
- “No opinion” is an allowed target position, but the target must still make a statement within 10 business days.
- Best-price looks at what’s paid in the offer. Rule 14e-5 is what stops side purchases during the offer.
- The 10-business-day order doesn’t help a hostile bid, a stock offer or a Dutch auction.
How it's tested
Counting offer periods, applying best-price and proration to a fact pattern, which rule governs a given action, and what the target must do and by when.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson