Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Securities Act liability
Securities Act liability
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
Who can be sued over offering disclosure and on what terms: Sections 11, 12, 17 and 23, the due diligence defense, damages and time limits, and the safe harbor for forward-looking statements.
The rules
- Section 11: a buyer can sue if any part of the registration statement, when it became effective, had a material misstatement or omission, unless the buyer knew. No reliance needs proving, unless the buyer bought after the issuer published an earning statement covering 12 months after effectiveness.
- Who is liable under Section 11: everyone who signed, directors at the time of filing, people named as about to become directors, experts who consented to being named (for their own parts only), and every underwriter.
- Due diligence defense: the issuer has none. Everyone else may show that, after reasonable investigation, they had reasonable ground to believe the statement was true. For a part resting on someone else’s expert report, no investigation is needed, only no reasonable ground to believe it was false. The standard is a prudent person managing their own property (Section 11(c)).
- Rule 176 lists what bears on reasonableness: the type of issuer, security and person, the office held, other relationships to the issuer, reasonable reliance on officers and employees, the underwriter’s arrangement, role and access to information, and responsibility for documents incorporated by reference.
- Section 11 damages: the price paid (no more than the public offering price) minus the value at suit, or the sale price if sold before suit. A sale after suit but before judgment uses the sale price only if that makes damages smaller. Defendants can cut this by proving the drop had another cause. Recovery can’t exceed the public offering price. Each underwriter’s exposure is capped at the total offering price of the shares it underwrote, unless it took a special benefit from the issuer. Liability is joint and several, with outside directors treated under the proportionate rules for private securities suits.
- Section 12(a)(1): anyone who offers or sells in violation of Section 5 is liable to the buyer, with no fault needed. Section 12(a)(2): a seller using a prospectus or oral communication with a material misstatement is liable unless it shows it didn’t know and with reasonable care couldn’t have known. The remedy is money back with interest, less income received, or damages if the buyer has sold. In a Section 12(a)(2) case the seller can cut this by proving the loss came from something else (Section 12(b)). In a primary offering the issuer counts as a seller (Rule 159A), and the Supreme Court’s Gustafson decision confines 12(a)(2) to public offerings.
- Time limits (Section 13): Section 11 and 12(a)(2) claims run one year from discovery; Section 12(a)(1) claims run one year from the violation. The outer limit is three years from the bona fide public offering (Sections 11 and 12(a)(1)) or from the sale (Section 12(a)(2)).
- Section 17(a): bars fraud in the offer or sale of any security, including exempt ones, and is mainly an enforcement tool. Section 17(a)(1) requires scienter; 17(a)(2) and (3) don’t (Aaron v. SEC). Section 17(b) bars paid promotion of a security without disclosing the payment.
- Section 23: filing or effectiveness isn’t a finding that the registration statement is accurate or that the SEC approved the security, and telling a buyer otherwise is unlawful.
- Rule 175 and Rule 3b-6: forward-looking statements (projections, management’s plans, MD&A on future performance, and their assumptions) in SEC filings aren’t fraudulent unless shown to lack a reasonable basis or to be made other than in good faith. Rule 175 applies under the Securities Act and Rule 3b-6 under the Exchange Act. Non-reporting issuers can use Rule 175 in a registration statement, whereas the statutory safe harbor in Section 27A excludes IPOs.
Formulas
- Section 11 damages: Price paid (capped at the public offering price) − value at suit, or sale price if sold before suit (a sale after suit counts only if it lowers damages)
- Section 12 rescission: Price paid + interest − income received, on tender of the security
Common traps
- The issuer has no due diligence defense under Section 11.
- Section 11 reaches the registration statement. An FWP filed under Rule 433 isn’t part of it, so FWP risk runs through Sections 12(a)(2) and 17(a).
- Section 12(a)(1) runs one year from the violation, not from discovery.
- An underwriter needn’t investigate audited financials, but it must investigate everything not resting on an expert.
- Experts answer only for the parts they prepared or certified.
- Calling a deal SEC-approved violates Section 23, even after effectiveness.
How it's tested
Naming who is liable and which defense each person has, computing Section 11 damages, and applying the Section 13 time limits.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson