Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Resales: Rules 144, 144A & Regulation S
Resales: Rules 144, 144A & Regulation S
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
How restricted and control securities get resold without registration: Rule 144’s conditions, Rule 144A sales to QIBs, and Regulation S offshore sales and resales.
The rules
- Why Rule 144 exists: Section 4(a)(1) exempts transactions by anyone other than an issuer, underwriter or dealer, and a holder who buys from an issuer and quickly resells can look like an underwriter. Rule 144 is a non-exclusive safe harbor: meet it and you aren’t one, and the buyer receives unrestricted securities.
- Restricted or control: restricted securities come from the issuer or an affiliate in a non-public deal, such as Regulation D or Rule 144A. Control securities are any securities held by an affiliate, meaning someone who controls, is controlled by or is under common control with the issuer. An affiliate selling shares bought in the market has no holding period but must meet the other conditions.
- Holding period: six months if the issuer has been reporting for at least 90 days; one year if not. It starts when the full price is paid and runs from acquisition from the issuer or an affiliate, so a later non-affiliate buyer can count an earlier non-affiliate’s time.
- Non-affiliates (not an affiliate now or in the past three months): for a reporting issuer, they may sell after six months with current public information, and freely after one year. For a non-reporting issuer, they sell freely after one year. No volume, manner of sale or Form 144 conditions apply.
- Affiliates must meet everything: current public information, the holding period for restricted securities, the volume limit, manner of sale and Form 144.
- Volume limit: in any three months, the greater of 1% of the class outstanding or average weekly trading volume over the four calendar weeks before the Form 144. Debt can use 10% of the tranche instead. Sales by relatives sharing a home, by trusts and companies they’re tied to, and by people acting in concert are added together.
- Manner of sale and Form 144: equity must be sold in brokers’ transactions, directly with a market maker or as riskless principal, with no solicitation. File Form 144 at the same time as the order if the sale exceeds 5,000 shares or $50,000 in three months: electronically for a reporting issuer, on paper (three copies) for a non-reporting issuer. Rule 144 isn’t available for shell company securities until the issuer has stopped being a shell, is reporting and is current, and a year has passed since it filed Form 10 information.
- Rule 144A: resales to qualified institutional buyers (QIBs). A QIB owns and invests on a discretionary basis at least $100 million of unaffiliated securities; a registered dealer needs $10 million, or can act as riskless principal for a QIB; banks and savings institutions also need $25 million of audited net worth. The seller must reasonably believe the buyer is a QIB and make it aware of the reliance. The class can’t be listed on a U.S. exchange or quoted on a U.S. automated system, and for a non-reporting issuer holders can ask for basic information. The securities stay restricted.
- Regulation S: Section 5 doesn’t reach offers and sales outside the United States (Rule 901). Two conditions apply throughout, both defined in Rule 902. An offshore transaction means no offer to a person in the U.S., and either the buyer is outside the U.S. when the order originates (or the seller reasonably believes so) or the trade runs through a qualifying offshore market. Directed selling efforts are activity that could condition the U.S. market, such as an ad in a publication with general U.S. circulation. Rule 903 covers issuers and distributors; Rule 904 covers resales by others.
- Regulation S categories (Rule 903): Category 1 (such as a foreign issuer with no substantial U.S. market interest): no further conditions. Category 2 (equity of reporting foreign issuers; debt of reporting issuers and non-reporting foreign issuers): offering restrictions and a 40-day distribution compliance period. Category 3 (everything else): debt 40 days; equity one year, or six months for a reporting issuer, with buyer certifications and legends. Equity of domestic issuers stays restricted (Rule 905).
Formulas
- Rule 144 volume limit (equity, any 3 months): Greater of 1% of shares outstanding or average weekly volume over the prior 4 calendar weeks
- Rule 144 volume limit (debt): Greater of the equity test or 10% of the tranche
Common traps
- Control securities bought in the market have no holding period, but volume, manner of sale and Form 144 still apply.
- The volume test uses the greater of the two figures, not the lesser.
- Between months 6 and 12, a non-affiliate of a reporting issuer still needs current public information.
- An accredited investor isn’t automatically a QIB.
- Form 144 goes in with the order, not after the sale.
- Regulation S equity of a U.S. issuer is restricted, so it can’t simply flow back into the U.S.
How it's tested
Computing the Rule 144 volume limit, separating affiliate from non-affiliate conditions, testing QIB status and choosing a Regulation S category.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson