Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Fairness opinions
Fairness opinions
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
When a board seeks a fairness opinion, how the analysis is built and approved, what FINRA Rule 5150 requires a firm to disclose and to have in writing, and how the opinion appears in a proxy statement.
The rules
- What it is: a letter from a financial adviser to a board or special committee saying that, as of its date and on stated assumptions, the consideration is fair from a financial point of view to the holders it names (or to the company, for a buyer). It isn’t advice on how to vote or a statement that the price is the highest available.
- When one is sought: generally no law requires one. Boards get them to show an informed process, especially after Smith v. Van Gorkom (Del. 1985), where directors were found grossly negligent in approving a merger despite a large premium. They’re common in sales of public companies, conflicted deals, going-private deals and special committee processes. Buyers’ boards get them too.
- The analysis: the team reviews projections and public data, then runs comparable companies, precedent transactions and DCF, plus premiums paid or LBO analysis where relevant. The price is compared with the resulting ranges. Banks typically rely on management’s projections rather than verifying them.
- Approval path: the analysis goes to the firm’s internal approval or fairness committee, then to the client and its board or special committee at a fairness meeting. The team also helps draft the letter and the proxy disclosure, and follows internal procedures for disclosing conflicts.
- FINRA 5150 disclosures: if the firm knows or has reason to know the opinion will be provided or described to public shareholders, it must disclose (1) whether it advised any party and has a fee contingent on completion; (2) any other significant contingent payment; (3) material relationships in the past 2 years, or expected ones, involving compensation from a party; (4) whether it independently verified key information from the company, and if so what; (5) whether a fairness committee approved or issued the opinion; (6) whether it addresses the fairness of insiders’ pay relative to what public shareholders receive.
- FINRA 5150 procedures: any firm issuing fairness opinions needs written approval procedures covering when it uses a fairness committee and, for those deals, how members are selected, what qualifications they need, and how a balanced review is promoted, including review and approval by people outside the deal team. The procedures must also cover how the firm decides whether its valuation analyses are appropriate.
- Conflicts are disclosed, not banned: a firm paid a success fee can still issue an opinion, but the fee must be disclosed. Some boards hire a second adviser on a fixed fee to reduce that concern.
- Proxy disclosure: if an outside opinion is referred to in a proxy statement (Schedule 14A, Item 14(b)(6)) or S-4 prospectus (Item 4(b)), the document gives the Item 1015(b) information from Regulation M-A: who gave it, their qualifications, how they were chosen, material relationships and pay in the past 2 years, who set the price, and a summary of the procedures, findings, methods and limits.
Common traps
- A fairness opinion says a price is fair, not that it’s the best price or that holders should vote yes.
- Rule 5150 is a disclosure and procedures rule. It doesn’t ban contingent fees and doesn’t require a fairness opinion.
- The six disclosures apply when the opinion will reach public shareholders; the written procedures apply to any firm issuing opinions.
- The disclosure says whether information was independently verified. It doesn’t require verification.
- The opinion speaks as of its date, so later events aren’t covered.
How it's tested
The six Rule 5150 disclosures, what written procedures must cover, why boards get opinions, and what a proxy statement must say about one.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson