Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Due diligence
Due diligence
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
Why bankers investigate before a deal: the material-misstatement standard, the Section 11 defense and Rule 176, bring-down checks and comfort letters, and how the sell-side and buy-side processes run, including data rooms.
The rules
- The standard: offering documents may not contain an untrue statement of a material fact or omit a material fact needed to keep the statements from misleading. A fact is material if there’s a substantial likelihood a reasonable investor would attach importance to it in deciding whether to buy (Rule 405).
- Section 11: a material misstatement in a registration statement, at the time that part became effective, exposes the issuer, signers, directors, named experts and underwriters. Everyone except the issuer can raise a due diligence defense.
- The defense: for non-expert parts, the defendant must show that after a reasonable investigation it had reasonable ground to believe, and did believe, the statements were true. For parts resting on someone else’s expert authority, such as audited financials, it must show it had no reasonable ground to believe they were untrue. The yardstick is a prudent person managing his or her own property.
- Rule 176: lists circumstances that bear on what’s reasonable for anyone but the issuer: the type of issuer, security and person; the office held; any other relationship to the issuer; reasonable reliance on people whose duties should have given them the facts; for an underwriter, the type of underwriting, its role and the availability of information; and responsibility for documents incorporated by reference.
- What the work covers: financial information and business plans; talks with management, vendors, suppliers and customers; site visits; and the identification of everything that must be disclosed. Auditor comfort letters, legal opinions and officers’ certificates back it up.
- Bring-down: a final check, usually a call with management and the auditors just before pricing and again before closing, that nothing has changed. Timing matters: Section 11 tests the document at effectiveness, each shelf takedown sets a new effective date for the issuer and underwriters (Rule 430B), and Section 12(a)(2) looks at what buyers had at the time of sale (Rule 159).
- Comfort letters (PCAOB AS 6101): the auditor’s letter to the underwriters on the financial data. It can give negative assurance on later changes only for a date less than 135 days after the end of the latest audited or reviewed period; after that, the auditor reports only procedures and findings.
- Sell-side process: diligence the seller’s own numbers first so nothing surprises a buyer, help gather materials, set the data room’s procedures and index, add supplemental information as questions arrive, monitor who opens what, and help the seller check the buyers, including their ability to pay.
- Buy-side process: coordinate management presentations, data room access and site visits. Investigate in confidence: benefits, pay and HR plans after closing, leadership (including background checks), culture, governance and labor issues, unfunded liabilities, off-balance-sheet items and cost savings. Find negotiating points, and use sources beyond the target, such as filings, court records and customers.
- Competitors in a data room: FTC staff guidance says to keep sharing of competitively sensitive information, such as current prices, costs and strategy, narrowly tied to a diligence need, and to use safeguards such as clean teams that exclude people who run pricing or strategy.
Common traps
- The issuer has no due diligence defense under Section 11; its liability is essentially strict.
- Audited financials are expertised. Reviewed interim numbers aren’t: a review report isn’t an expert’s report under Rule 436(c), so those numbers need a reasonable investigation.
- Rule 176 lists relevant circumstances. It isn’t a safe harbor or a checklist that guarantees the defense.
- Reliance must be reasonable. Reading a management answer into the file doesn’t cover a red flag; follow it up.
- Section 11 covers registration statements, so it doesn’t reach a private placement. Antifraud liability under Rule 10b-5 still does, which is why bankers run diligence there too.
- Diligence isn’t finished when the first pass is done. A clean review last month doesn’t cover a problem that appears the week of pricing.
How it's tested
Who has a Section 11 defense and what it requires, Rule 176 factors, expertised versus non-expertised information, bring-down and comfort letter timing, and sell-side versus buy-side tasks.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson