Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Comparable companies & precedent transactions
Comparable companies & precedent transactions
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
The two market-based valuation methods: what similar public companies trade at and what buyers have paid for similar businesses, how to gather the data, line it up and explain where a company sits against its peers.
The rules
- Two market checks: comparable companies show what public investors pay today for a small, liquid stake. Precedent transactions show what buyers paid for control of similar businesses.
- Picking peers: start with industry and business mix, then screen for size, growth, margins, geography and capital structure. No peer is perfect, so have a reason for each inclusion and exclusion.
- Spreading comps: pull figures from the latest 10-K and 10-Qs, the share count from the latest cover page, options and debt from the footnotes, and estimates from consensus. Use LTM and forward figures, strip out non-recurring items and calendarize so that every peer covers the same period.
- Positioning: compare the company’s growth, margins, returns and leverage with the group to explain why it deserves a premium or discount to the median. That’s relative valuation: the multiple alone doesn’t tell the story.
- Using the output: apply the peer range to the company’s metric to get an implied EV, then walk to equity value and a price per share, using the same diluted share and net debt steps as any EV calculation.
- Picking precedents: look for the same industry, similar size and deal type, and comparable market conditions. Keep a running list of deals by the firm and its competitors. Sources: merger proxies and Form S-4, Schedule TO and Schedule 14D-9 for tender offers, the 8-K announcing the deal, press releases and data vendors.
- Deal multiples: transaction EV = offer price × diluted shares at the offer price + net debt + preferred + noncontrolling interest. Divide by the target’s LTM metrics at announcement. A higher offer brings more options into the money.
- Premiums paid: compare the offer with the unaffected share price, before rumors or leaks, usually over several lookbacks such as one day, one week and four weeks.
- Why precedents usually run higher: they include a control premium and often expected synergies. They also reflect the rates, financing and sentiment of their day, so note what’s changed.
- Football field: bankers chart the value ranges from comps, precedents, DCF, LBO analysis and the 52-week trading range side by side to frame a recommendation.
- Precedent financing trends: beyond M&A multiples, review past deals for capital raising trends: capital restructurings, use of derivatives, share repurchase programs, tender offers, rights offerings and debt issuance. Registration and proxy statements are the main sources.
Formulas
- Implied EV: Peer multiple × company’s metric
- Implied share price: (Implied EV − net debt − preferred − noncontrolling interest) ÷ diluted shares
- Transaction EV: Offer price × diluted shares at offer + net debt + preferred + noncontrolling interest
- Takeover premium: Offer price ÷ unaffected share price − 1
- Calendarized metric: (Months of FY1 in the calendar year ÷ 12) × FY1 + (remaining months ÷ 12) × FY2
Common traps
- Trading comps carry no control premium, so a comps value and a takeover price aren’t the same thing.
- Measure a premium against the unaffected price. The price after a leak already contains part of the premium.
- One outlier can drag the mean, so lead with the median and explain anything you drop.
- A deal multiple uses diluted shares at the offer price, not the pre-deal share count.
- A precedent from a strategic buyer may include synergies a financial buyer can’t pay for.
- In a stock-for-stock deal the value moves with the buyer’s share price, so state the date and whether the exchange ratio is fixed.
How it's tested
Choosing peers and precedents, adjusting and calendarizing data, computing implied values and premiums, and explaining why methods give different answers.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson