Study guides / Series 79: Investment Banking Representative / Buy-side M&A
Buy-side M&A
Series 79: Investment Banking Representative · quick review
How a banker advises an acquirer: testing the rationale and synergies, valuing the target before bidding, financing the bid, dealing with the seller’s advisers and finishing diligence.
The rules
- Start with the buyer: assess its strategy, resources and financial capacity, the rationale for the deal (growth, scale, new markets, technology, cost savings) and the likely market reaction. Value the buyer’s own business too, because its stock may be the currency.
- Synergies: cost synergies (overlapping overhead, purchasing, facilities) are more reliable than revenue synergies (cross-selling, pricing). Model them after tax, phased in over time and net of integration costs. They justify paying above stand-alone value, but paying for all of them hands their value to the seller.
- Valuation before the bid: build stand-alone and pro forma values using comparable companies, precedent transactions, discounted cash flow (DCF) and leveraged buyout (LBO) analysis, which shows what a financial buyer could pay and still earn its target return. Also analyze the target’s results, market position and industry.
- Accretion and dilution: compare pro forma EPS with the buyer’s stand-alone EPS. Before synergies and purchase accounting, an all-stock deal is accretive if the buyer’s P/E is above the P/E it pays for the target. A cash or debt deal is accretive if the target’s earnings yield at the offer price exceeds the after-tax cost of the funds used.
- Financing the bid: the choices are cash on hand, new debt (bank loans, a bridge to bonds) and stock. Compare cost, leverage and credit rating effects, dilution and speed, and arrange commitments from lenders when needed. If the buyer will issue 20% or more of its common stock or voting power, measured before the issuance, NYSE and Nasdaq rules generally require its own shareholders to vote.
- Impediments: check early for shareholder rights plans, staggered boards, control share statutes, change-of-control terms in the target’s debt and contracts, and antitrust risk. Work with tax advisers on tax-free reorganization treatment, recapitalizations, Section 338(h)(10) elections and stock versus cash.
- Toeholds: buying target shares before a bid has consequences. Owning more than 5% requires a Schedule 13D within 5 business days of the purchase; a buyer with a control purpose can’t use the shorter Schedule 13G. HSR may also apply to the purchase.
- Bidding process: the banker reviews the CIM and NDA, helps develop preliminary bids, acts as liaison with the seller and its advisers, and tracks what rival bidders can do. In a public deal, the NDA’s standstill can limit going directly to shareholders.
- Follow-up diligence: requests target what could change price or structure: unfunded liabilities, off-balance-sheet items, benefits and compensation, labor and culture, governance, management quality and cost-saving opportunities. Sources beyond the target itself matter too.
- Closing out: the banker reviews the final bid with the buyer, helps with a fairness opinion if the buyer’s board wants one, and gives the buyer’s counsel and accountants the agreed financial terms.
Formulas
- Pro forma EPS: (Buyer net income + target net income + after-tax synergies − after-tax financing cost) ÷ (buyer shares + new shares issued)
- Accretion or dilution: (Pro forma EPS ÷ buyer stand-alone EPS) − 1
- New shares issued: Stock portion of the price ÷ buyer share price
- Exchange ratio: Offer price per target share ÷ buyer share price
- Premium paid: (Offer price − unaffected target price) ÷ unaffected target price
- Goodwill: Purchase price − fair value of net identifiable assets
Common traps
- Accretive doesn’t mean value-creating. A deal can lift EPS and still overpay.
- The P/E test uses the price paid (offer price ÷ target EPS), not the target’s market P/E before the bid.
- Precedent transaction multiples usually include a control premium; trading multiples don’t.
- Schedule 13D turns on owning more than 5%, not on whether a bid has been made.
How it's tested
Computing EPS accretion, an exchange ratio or a premium, comparing cash and stock financing, and spotting impediments before a bid.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson