Study guides / CON: Consulting Case Interviews / Structuring & hypotheses
Structuring & hypotheses
CON: Consulting Case Interviews · quick review
How to open a case: clarify the objective, build a clear structure, and work from a hypothesis instead of fishing for data.
The rules
- Clarify first: restate the prompt, confirm the objective (e.g., restore profit to last year's level within two years) and ask about anything unclear: geography, time frame, constraints.
- Build an issue tree that breaks the problem into parts that are MECE: mutually exclusive (no overlap) and collectively exhaustive (nothing missing).
- Tailor, don't recite: memorized frameworks are a starting point. Interviewers reward a structure built for this client's question.
- Be hypothesis-driven: state what you think the answer is likely to be, pick the branch that would test it, and revise when the data says otherwise.
- Case flow: clarify → structure → analyze each branch (with math and exhibits) → synthesize into a recommendation.
Formulas
- MECE check: no overlap between branches + nothing left out
- Profit tree: profit = revenue − costs = (price × volume) − (fixed + variable costs)
Common traps
- Jumping into analysis before confirming the objective.
- Branches that overlap, such as "costs" and "labor" as separate top-level buckets.
- Clinging to a first hypothesis after the data contradicts it.
How it's tested
Every case opens this way. Interviewers judge how clearly and logically you break down the problem before any numbers appear.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson