Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / REITs & public real estate
REITs & public real estate
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Publicly traded real estate securities and how to value them: REITs, REOCs and mortgage securities, net asset value per share, funds from operations (FFO) and adjusted FFO (AFFO), price multiples and discounted cash flow, and the pros and cons of public versus private real estate.
The rules
- Types: equity REITs own and operate income-producing property; mortgage REITs hold real estate loans and are more sensitive to interest rates; REOCs (real estate operating companies) are ordinary taxable companies that can retain earnings and develop or trade property freely; residential and commercial mortgage-backed securities are the public debt form.
- REIT tax status: a REIT pays little or no corporate income tax if it distributes most of its taxable income and meets asset and income tests. That gives high yields but limits growth from retained earnings, so REITs rely on raising outside capital to expand.
- NAVPS is the main valuation anchor, because book value, after years of depreciation, says little about market value. Value the operating property by capitalizing next year's expected cash NOI (excluding non-cash straight-line rent) at a market cap rate, add other assets (cash, receivables, land held), subtract all liabilities and divide by shares outstanding. Exclude goodwill and similar intangibles.
- Premium or discount to NAV: a price above NAVPS may reflect expected value creation by management or a market more optimistic than private appraisals; a discount may reflect weak management, governance concerns or expected falls in property values. Public prices tend to move before private appraisals do.
- FFO moves accounting net income toward recurring operating cash earnings: add back depreciation and amortization of real estate and deferred tax charges, and remove gains or losses on property sales and debt restructuring.
- AFFO refines FFO toward cash available to distribute: subtract non-cash (straight-line) rent and the recurring capital spending needed to maintain the properties, including tenant improvements and leasing commissions. It is the better measure of distributable cash but takes more estimates, so it varies by analyst.
- Relative value: P/FFO and P/AFFO compare a REIT with peers and its own history. A REIT deserves a higher multiple for stronger growth, lower leverage and better-quality property. FFO ignores maintenance capital spending; AFFO captures it.
- Discounted cash flow: discount forecast dividends for several years, then add a terminal value from a growth model or a P/AFFO multiple applied to forecast AFFO. This suits REITs because their cash flows are fairly predictable and mostly paid out.
- Public versus private: public securities offer liquidity, small minimum investments, diversification across properties, professional management, limited liability, price transparency and, for REITs, no corporate tax. Drawbacks: little control, stock-market volatility in the short run, the costs of a public structure, limited growth from retained earnings and possible conflicts of interest (for example in UPREIT structures, where insiders hold operating partnership units with different tax positions).
Formulas
- Value of operating real estate: Value = next year's cash NOI ÷ market cap rate
- Net asset value: NAV = value of operating real estate + other assets − total liabilities
- NAV per share: NAVPS = NAV ÷ shares outstanding
- Funds from operations: FFO = net income + real estate depreciation and amortization + deferred tax charges + losses − gains on property sales and debt restructuring
- Adjusted FFO: AFFO = FFO − non-cash (straight-line) rent − recurring maintenance capital spending and leasing costs
- Relative value: Value per share = P/FFO (or P/AFFO) multiple × FFO (or AFFO) per share
- Dividend discount: V0 = Σ Dt ÷ (1 + r)^t + Pn ÷ (1 + r)^n
Common traps
- Capitalize next year's cash NOI, not current accounting NOI that includes straight-line rent.
- FFO adds back real estate depreciation (not other depreciation) and strips out property sale gains; it doesn't deduct capital spending, which is why AFFO exists.
- AFFO subtracts straight-line rent and recurring capital spending from FFO; don't add them.
- Book value per share isn't NAV; depreciation leaves it far below market value.
How it's tested
Vignettes give a REIT's financial statements and ask for NAVPS, FFO or AFFO, a value from P/FFO or P/AFFO, or a judgment on investing through public versus private vehicles.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson