Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Private company valuation
Private company valuation
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
How valuing a private business differs from valuing a public one: purposes and standards of value, normalizing earnings, required returns (CAPM, expanded CAPM, build-up), discounts for lack of control and marketability, and the income, market and asset-based approaches.
The rules
- Company-specific differences: private firms are often earlier in their life cycle and smaller, owners often manage them, management is thinner, financial information is of lower quality, there is less pressure from short-term investors and more tax-driven decisions. Stock-specific differences: shares are illiquid, often restricted, and ownership is concentrated.
- Uses: transactions (venture financing, IPOs, sales of the business, bankruptcy, performance-based pay), compliance (financial reporting such as goodwill impairment, and tax) and litigation. Analysts start with the purpose, the standard (definition) of value it requires, and whether the interest is controlling or not.
- Normalized earnings strip out nonrecurring items, above- or below-market owner pay, personal expenses run through the business, related-party deals at non-market terms and income from nonoperating assets. Property the business owns but doesn't need is valued separately and replaced with a market rent. These adjustments fit a controlling interest; a minority holder can't make them happen.
- Strategic versus financial buyers: a strategic buyer's forecast cash flows include synergies, so it can pay more than a financial buyer, whose value rests on the business as it stands.
- Discount rate issues: size premiums, betas that can't be measured directly, debt that is costlier and harder to get (raising WACC), the need to use the target's risk rather than the acquirer's, projection risk in management forecasts, the life-cycle stage and company-specific risk.
- Required return models: the CAPM with a beta from public peers; the expanded CAPM, which adds size and company-specific premiums; and the build-up approach, which assumes a beta of 1 and adds the equity, size and company-specific premiums to the risk-free rate, with an industry adjustment if needed. Avoid counting the same risk in both the size and company-specific premiums.
- Control and marketability discounts: a discount for lack of control (DLOC) converts a control value to a minority value and is derived from control premiums. A discount for lack of marketability (DLOM) reflects the cost of being unable to sell readily; estimate it from restricted stock studies, pre-IPO transactions or the price of a put option. Combine them by multiplying, not adding.
- Income approach: the free cash flow method (multi-period DCF); the capitalized cash flow method (a single-stage model for stable growth); and the excess earnings method, which charges required returns on working capital and fixed assets, capitalizes the earnings left over as the value of intangibles, and adds the three values.
- Market approach: the guideline public company method uses public peers' multiples, adjusted for risk and growth, plus a control premium when valuing control. The guideline transactions method uses multiples paid for whole companies, which already include control; watch for synergies, contingent or noncash consideration and stale deals. The prior transaction method uses past sales of the subject's own shares and suits minority interests.
- Asset-based approach: fair value of assets − fair value of liabilities. It's rarely used for operating going concerns but suits holding and investment companies, natural resource firms, very early-stage firms and liquidations.
- Choosing an approach: income for firms with forecastable cash flows; market when good comparables exist, usually for mature firms; asset-based when assets drive value or the firm will be liquidated. Using more than one approach and reconciling them is common.
Formulas
- Expanded CAPM: r = Rf + β × ERP + size premium + company-specific premium
- Build-up method: r = Rf + ERP + size premium + company-specific premium (± industry adjustment)
- Capitalized cash flow: Firm value = FCFF1 ÷ (WACC − g); equity value = FCFE1 ÷ (r − g)
- Excess earnings method: Excess earnings = normalized earnings − r(WC) × working capital − r(FA) × fixed assets; intangibles = next year's excess earnings ÷ (r(intangibles) − g); firm value = working capital + fixed assets + intangibles
- DLOC from a control premium: DLOC = 1 − 1 ÷ (1 + control premium)
- Combined discount: Total discount = 1 − (1 − DLOC) × (1 − DLOM)
Common traps
- DLOC and DLOM combine by multiplication; adding them overstates the discount.
- Guideline transaction multiples already include control, so don't add a control premium to them.
- Normalizing owner pay belongs in a control valuation; a minority interest takes the business as it is run.
- Use the target's risk for the discount rate, not the acquirer's lower cost of capital.
How it's tested
Vignettes describe a private firm and a buyer and ask for normalized earnings, a build-up or expanded CAPM return, a value by a stated method, or the combined effect of DLOC and DLOM.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson