Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Market multiples
Market multiples
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Valuing stocks with price and enterprise value multiples: comparables versus justified multiples from fundamentals, P/E, P/B, P/S, P/CF, dividend yield and EV/EBITDA, normalized earnings, PEG, regression-based P/Es, terminal values, cross-border issues, momentum indicators and how to average multiples.
The rules
- Two approaches: the method of comparables values a stock against a benchmark multiple (peer median, industry or index), resting on the law of one price; it shows relative value only. The method based on forecasted fundamentals derives a justified multiple from a discounted cash flow model, tying the multiple to growth, risk and profitability.
- P/E: earning power drives value and the ratio is widely used, but it fails with negative earnings, and reported earnings carry one-off items and management choices. Use underlying earnings that strip out nonrecurring items. Use the earnings yield (E/P) when earnings are negative or near zero, for example to rank stocks.
- Normalized EPS removes the business cycle. The historical average EPS method averages EPS over a full cycle but ignores changes in company size. The average ROE method (average ROE over the cycle × current book value per share) reflects size changes and is generally preferred.
- P/B: book value is usually positive and stable, and suits financial firms whose assets are mostly at market value and companies likely to be liquidated. Drawbacks: it ignores intangibles such as human capital and is distorted by accounting choices, inflation, buybacks and old asset costs. Analysts often use tangible book value and adjust for off-balance-sheet items.
- P/S, P/CF and dividend yield: sales are positive even when earnings aren't and are harder to manipulate, but say nothing about costs or profit, and revenue recognition can be stretched. Price is an equity value while sales belong to the whole firm, so EV/sales suits leveraged firms. P/CF uses less manipulable cash flow (earnings plus noncash charges, adjusted CFO, FCFE or EBITDA). Dividend yield is part of total return but ignores capital gains.
- Fundamentals behind multiples: justified multiples rise with expected growth and fall with the required return. P/B exceeds 1 only when ROE exceeds r. P/S rises with the profit margin. A higher payout raises P/E only if growth is held constant.
- Regression P/E: a cross-sectional regression of P/Es on fundamentals (such as payout, growth and beta) gives a predicted P/E to compare with the actual one. Limits: the relationships hold only for that sample and period, and the predictors are often correlated with each other (multicollinearity), which makes coefficients unreliable.
- PEG = P/E ÷ expected growth in percent; a lower PEG suggests a cheaper stock. It assumes P/E and growth are linearly related, ignores risk and how long growth will last, and means nothing for zero or negative growth.
- EV multiples: EV includes debt, so the denominator must be a pre-interest flow such as EBITDA, EBIT, FCFF or sales. EV/EBITDA suits comparing firms with different leverage and heavy depreciation, and EBITDA is often positive when EPS isn't. But EBITDA overstates cash flow when working capital is growing and ignores capital spending.
- Cross-border comparisons are distorted by different accounting standards, culture, risk and growth; cash flow multiples such as P/CFO and P/FCFE are the least affected, while P/B, P/E and EBITDA-based multiples, which start from accounting book value or earnings, are the most affected. Momentum indicators (earnings surprise, standardized unexpected earnings and relative strength) compare price or earnings with their own history, expectations or a benchmark.
- Averaging and terminal values: the arithmetic mean is pulled up by large outliers; the median resists outliers; the harmonic mean dampens large outliers but magnifies small ones; the weighted harmonic mean with market-value weights gives the portfolio's own P/E. In a multistage DCF, a terminal value = benchmark multiple × the forecast fundamental at the horizon.
Formulas
- Justified leading P/E: P0 ÷ E1 = (1 − b) ÷ (r − g)
- Justified trailing P/E: P0 ÷ E0 = (1 − b) × (1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
- Justified P/B: P0 ÷ B0 = (ROE − g) ÷ (r − g)
- Justified P/S: P0 ÷ S0 = (E0 ÷ S0) × (1 − b) × (1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
- Justified dividend yield: D0 ÷ P0 = (r − g) ÷ (1 + g)
- Earnings yield: E/P = EPS ÷ price
- Normalized EPS (average ROE): Normalized EPS = average ROE × current book value per share
- PEG ratio: PEG = (P/E) ÷ g, with g in percent
- Predicted P/E: Plug the stock's payout, growth and risk into the fitted regression: b0 + b1 × payout + b2 × growth + b3 × beta
- Enterprise value: EV = market value of common + market value of preferred + market value of debt − cash and short-term investments
- EV/EBITDA: EV ÷ EBITDA
- Terminal value from a multiple: TVn = benchmark multiple × forecast fundamental (leading P/E × EPS for n + 1, trailing P/E × EPS for n)
- Harmonic mean: n ÷ Σ(1 ÷ Xi)
- Weighted harmonic mean: 1 ÷ Σ(wi ÷ Xi)
- Standardized unexpected earnings: SUE = (reported EPS − expected EPS) ÷ standard deviation of past unexpected earnings
Common traps
- Match numerator and denominator: equity value with equity flows (EPS, FCFE, book value), EV with whole-firm flows (EBITDA, FCFF, sales).
- Relatively cheap isn't absolutely cheap; the whole peer group may be overvalued.
- A leading P/E pairs with next year's EPS and a trailing P/E with last year's; mixing them misstates value.
- The arithmetic mean of multiples with an extreme outlier misleads; use the median or harmonic mean.
How it's tested
Vignettes give peer multiples and fundamentals and ask for a justified multiple, normalized EPS, a predicted P/E or PEG, the right averaging method, or whether a stock looks relatively cheap or expensive.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson