Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Intercorporate investments
Intercorporate investments
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
How IFRS and US GAAP account for investments in other companies by degree of influence (financial assets, associates, joint ventures, business combinations, and special purpose or variable interest entities) and how each method changes reported results and ratios.
The rules
- Classification by influence: little or no influence (usually under 20% of voting power) means a financial asset. Significant influence (usually 20%–50%, or signs such as board seats, a say in policy, material intercompany transactions, shared managers or technology dependence) means an associate, under the equity method. Joint control means a joint venture, also under the equity method in both frameworks, with narrow exceptions. Control (usually over 50%) means a business combination, which is consolidated. The percentages are guides; substance decides.
- Financial assets under IFRS 9: debt held only to collect contractual cash flows of principal and interest is at amortized cost; debt held both to collect and to sell is at fair value through OCI (gains recycled to profit on sale); everything else is at fair value through profit or loss. Equity is at fair value through profit or loss unless, at purchase, a non-trading holding is irrevocably designated FVOCI: its gains never pass through profit, only its dividends. Debt is reclassified only if the business model changes; equity can't be reclassified.
- US GAAP differences: debt securities are held-to-maturity (amortized cost), available-for-sale (fair value through OCI) or trading (fair value through net income). Equity investments without significant influence generally go through net income at fair value; there's no OCI option for equity. Both frameworks use expected credit loss models to impair debt carried at amortized cost.
- Equity method: record the investment at cost, add the investor's share of the investee's net income and subtract dividends received (dividends return capital; they aren't income). The investment is one line on the balance sheet and equity income one line on the income statement. Losses cut the carrying amount to zero but not below, unless the investor has guaranteed the investee's obligations.
- Excess purchase price: the amount paid above the investor's share of the investee's book value goes first to the investor's share of fair value over book value of identifiable assets, and the rest is goodwill. Excess allocated to depreciable assets is depreciated, reducing equity income; goodwill isn't amortized and stays inside the investment's carrying amount. Impairment is tested on the investment as a whole.
- Intercompany profits: under the equity method, the investor defers its share of unrealized profit on goods still held by the buyer, for both downstream (investor to investee) and upstream (investee to investor) sales, and recognizes it when the goods are sold to outsiders or used up.
- Fair value option: US GAAP lets an investor elect fair value through profit or loss for an equity-method investment; IFRS allows this only for venture capital firms, mutual funds and similar entities.
- Acquisition method: the acquirer consolidates 100% of the target's identifiable assets and liabilities at fair value, including intangibles the target never recorded such as in-process R&D, and recognizes goodwill. Acquisition costs and restructuring costs are expensed, not added to the price. Contingent consideration is recorded at fair value on the acquisition date; if it's a liability, later changes in its fair value go through profit or loss. A bargain purchase is recognized as a gain in profit or loss right away.
- Goodwill and noncontrolling interest: under full goodwill, noncontrolling interest (NCI) is measured at fair value and goodwill is the fair value of the whole acquiree minus the fair value of its identifiable net assets; US GAAP requires this. IFRS also allows partial goodwill: NCI at its share of identifiable net assets and goodwill equal to the price paid minus the acquirer's share of identifiable net assets. Full goodwill gives higher assets and equity, so lower ROA and ROE. Goodwill isn't amortized, is tested for impairment at least annually, and goodwill impairments are never reversed.
- Effect on statements and ratios: compared with the equity method, consolidation shows higher revenue, expenses, assets and liabilities but the same net income attributable to the parent and the same parent equity. The equity method therefore shows a higher net profit margin, higher ROA and lower leverage, and keeps the investee's debt off the balance sheet; analysts may look through it to the underlying assets and debt.
- Special purpose and variable interest entities: under IFRS 10, consolidate any entity you control (power over it, exposure to its variable returns, and the ability to use that power to affect those returns), whatever the voting stake. Under US GAAP, the primary beneficiary of a VIE (with the power to direct its most significant activities and the obligation to absorb losses or right to receive significant benefits) consolidates it. Consolidating an SPE used to securitize receivables turns a reported sale into a secured borrowing: receivables stay on the balance sheet, debt rises, and the cash comes in as financing, not operating, cash flow.
Formulas
- Equity-method carrying amount: Cost + share of investee net income − dividends received − amortization of excess purchase price − impairment
- Equity income: Ownership % × investee net income − amortization of excess allocated to depreciable assets − ownership % × unrealized intercompany profit deferred (+ earlier deferrals now realized)
- Excess purchase price: Price paid − ownership % × book value of investee net assets
- Excess allocated to an asset: Ownership % × (fair value − book value) of the asset; the remainder is goodwill
- Full goodwill: Fair value of the entire acquiree − fair value of identifiable net assets
- Partial goodwill: Purchase price − acquirer % × fair value of identifiable net assets
- Noncontrolling interest: Full goodwill: NCI % × fair value of the acquiree; partial goodwill: NCI % × fair value of identifiable net assets
Common traps
- Dividends from an associate reduce the investment's carrying amount; they are not income.
- Under the equity method only the investor's share of unrealized intercompany profit is deferred, for upstream and downstream sales alike.
- Consolidation and the equity method give the parent the same net income; they differ in revenue, assets, liabilities and therefore ratios.
- IFRS FVOCI equity gains never recycle to profit, and US GAAP has no OCI option for equity investments.
How it's tested
Vignettes describe an investment and its terms; you choose the method, compute equity income, the carrying amount, goodwill or NCI, or compare ratios under consolidation, the equity method, and full versus partial goodwill.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson