Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Integrated analysis
Integrated analysis
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Putting financial statement analysis to work: a step-by-step framework tied to the question being asked, spotting reporting choices that distort comparisons, and adjusting balance sheets, earnings and cash flows so companies can be compared, rated and valued.
The rules
- Framework: (1) state the purpose and context, such as valuing equity from comparables, critiquing a credit rating, getting a full picture of leverage or testing management's commentary; (2) collect the data; (3) process it (adjust, compute ratios, common-size statements); (4) analyze and interpret; (5) develop and communicate conclusions and recommendations; (6) follow up. The purpose decides which data and adjustments matter.
- DuPont decomposition: break ROE into tax burden × interest burden × EBIT margin × asset turnover × leverage to see what drives changes in return. Remove equity-method income (and the investment from assets) to see the return from the company's own operations; a rising ROE driven by leverage or associates is lower quality than one driven by margins or turnover.
- Reporting choices that hurt comparability: revenue recognition timing, inventory cost flow (LIFO is allowed only under US GAAP), depreciation methods and useful lives, capitalizing versus expensing (IFRS capitalizes development costs that meet its criteria; US GAAP generally expenses R&D), asset revaluation (IFRS only), investment classification, lease presentation, pension assumptions and cash flow classification. Biased choices push results toward management's goals.
- Inventory: convert LIFO to FIFO by adding the LIFO reserve to inventory, raising equity by the reserve × (1 − tax rate) and deferred taxes by the reserve × tax rate. FIFO COGS = LIFO COGS − the increase in the LIFO reserve. A LIFO liquidation (inventory quantities falling) runs old, cheap costs through COGS and inflates margins temporarily.
- Long-lived assets: estimate average age (accumulated depreciation ÷ depreciation expense), total useful life (gross PP&E ÷ depreciation expense) and remaining life (net PP&E ÷ depreciation expense). Longer lives or higher salvage values than peers lift earnings, and older assets signal coming capital spending. Consider excluding goodwill when comparing an acquisitive company with one that grew organically.
- Leases and off-balance-sheet items: IFRS and US GAAP both put most leases on the balance sheet, but an IFRS lessee reports depreciation and interest (higher EBITDA, with principal repayments in financing cash flow), while a US GAAP operating lease shows a single lease cost in operating expense and all payments in operating cash flow. Adjust before comparing EBITDA, operating cash flow and leverage. For a full picture of leverage, add pension deficits, guarantees and debt of unconsolidated entities.
- Earnings normalization: remove items that won't recur (gains on asset sales, litigation settlements, unusual impairments), but treat “non-recurring” charges that show up every year as ongoing costs. Adjust for different accounting methods and for share-based pay and pension components that peers present differently. Use normalized earnings for multiples and forecasts.
- Cash flow modifications: reclassify items that distort operating cash flow: capitalized interest (move it from investing to operating outflows), securitized or factored receivables and supplier finance arrangements (they shift cash between periods), and differences in where interest and dividends are classified. Compare operating cash flow with earnings; a persistent gap points to accruals.
- Changes in standards, methods or estimates: a change in accounting policy is applied retrospectively (prior periods restated); a change in estimate (useful life, salvage value, bad debt rate) is applied prospectively; an error is fixed by restating prior periods. Trace each change through the statements: putting leases on the balance sheet raises assets, liabilities and debt to equity, while a longer useful life lowers depreciation and lifts margins and ROA.
- Deferred taxes and investments: a deferred tax liability not expected to reverse is closer to equity than debt; one expected to reverse is a liability. Different investment classifications (fair value through profit or loss, through OCI, or equity method) change earnings volatility and ROE; restate to a common basis before comparing.
- Using adjusted data: for credit work, recompute coverage and leverage after adjustments (lease and pension debt, capitalized interest added back to interest expense). For equity comparables, apply multiples only to adjusted, comparable earnings and book values. Test management's commentary against the adjusted numbers rather than accepting its framing.
Formulas
- Five-way DuPont: ROE = (net income ÷ EBT) × (EBT ÷ EBIT) × (EBIT ÷ revenue) × (revenue ÷ average assets) × (average assets ÷ average equity)
- FIFO inventory: LIFO inventory + LIFO reserve
- FIFO COGS: LIFO COGS − (ending LIFO reserve − beginning LIFO reserve)
- Equity adjustment for the LIFO reserve: LIFO reserve × (1 − tax rate)
- Average age of PP&E: Accumulated depreciation ÷ depreciation expense
- Average total useful life: Gross PP&E ÷ depreciation expense
- Remaining useful life: Net PP&E ÷ depreciation expense
- Interest coverage with capitalized interest: EBIT ÷ (interest expense + capitalized interest)
- Net operating assets (NOA): (Total assets − cash) − (total liabilities − total debt)
- Balance-sheet accruals ratio: (NOA end − NOA beginning) ÷ [(NOA end + NOA beginning) ÷ 2]
- Cash-flow accruals ratio: [Net income − (operating cash flow + investing cash flow)] ÷ [(NOA end + NOA beginning) ÷ 2]
Common traps
- Removing equity-method income changes both the margin and the asset turnover in DuPont; associates can mask weak core operations.
- Add the full LIFO reserve to inventory but only its after-tax amount to equity.
- For the same economics, an IFRS lessee reports higher EBITDA and operating cash flow than a US GAAP lessee with operating leases.
- A change in estimate is prospective; don't restate prior years for it.
How it's tested
Case-style item sets give two companies' statements and notes; you make comparability adjustments (inventory, leases, pensions, capitalized interest), compute adjusted ratios or accruals measures, decompose ROE, or judge how an accounting change alters the picture.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson