Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Forward commitments
Forward commitments
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
No-arbitrage pricing and valuation of forwards, futures and swaps: the carry arbitrage model, equity forwards and futures, forward rate agreements and interest rate futures, bond futures, and interest rate, currency and equity swaps.
The rules
- Carry arbitrage: a forward price equals the future value of the spot price, less the future value of any benefits from holding the asset (dividends, coupons) and plus any costs (such as storage). If the forward is priced too high, do a cash-and-carry: borrow, buy spot and sell forward. If too low, a reverse cash-and-carry: short spot, lend and buy forward.
- Price versus value: the forward price is set so the contract's value is zero at initiation. Later, a long forward's value = PV of (today's forward price for the same expiry − the original forward price), or equivalently spot − PV of remaining benefits − PV of the original forward price. At expiry it's spot − forward price.
- Equity forwards and futures: subtract the PV of discrete dividends from the spot price, or for an index use a continuous dividend yield. Futures are marked to market daily. Futures and forward prices are equal when interest rates are constant; futures prices are higher when the underlying's price is positively correlated with interest rates.
- Forward rate agreements: a long FRA pays fixed and receives floating, so it gains when rates rise. The FRA rate is the forward rate implied by two spot reference rates. Settlement = rate difference × notional × accrual period, discounted from the end of the borrowing period to the settlement date.
- Interest rate futures are quoted as 100 − the annualized futures rate, so a long position gains when rates fall. Their basis point value = notional × 0.01% × the accrual period.
- Bond futures: the short chooses which eligible bond to deliver. A conversion factor puts each bond on a common footing, and the short delivers the cheapest-to-deliver. The quoted futures price = [future value of the full spot price − accrued interest at delivery − future value of coupons received] ÷ conversion factor.
- Interest rate swaps are a series of FRAs, or a long fixed-rate bond and a short floating-rate bond. The fixed swap rate makes the PV of fixed payments equal the floating leg (par). Later, a receive-fixed swap is worth (original swap rate − current swap rate for the remaining term) × the sum of remaining discount factors × notional, with rates per payment period; a pay-fixed swap is worth the negative.
- Currency swaps: each leg is a bond in its own currency. Each fixed rate is set from that currency's discount factors, and notionals are exchanged at the spot rate at initiation and swapped back at maturity. Later, value = PV of the leg received − PV of the leg paid, converting one leg at the current spot rate.
- Equity swaps: one side pays the equity return (and receives it if negative), the other a fixed or floating rate. The fixed rate is set like a plain vanilla swap rate. Later, the equity leg is worth (current index level ÷ level at the last reset) × notional; subtract the PV of the fixed or floating leg.
Formulas
- Forward price (no carry): F0 = S0 × (1 + r)^T
- Forward price with carry: F0 = (S0 − PV of benefits + PV of costs) × (1 + r)^T
- Continuous dividend yield: F0 = S0 × e^((rc − δ) × T)
- Value of a long forward at t: Vt = (Ft − F0) ÷ (1 + r)^(T−t) = St − PV(remaining benefits) − F0 ÷ (1 + r)^(T−t)
- FRA rate: FRA = {[1 + L(h+m) × t(h+m)] ÷ [1 + L(h) × t(h)] − 1} ÷ t(m)
- FRA settlement (long): Payment = notional × (MRR − FRA) × t(m) ÷ [1 + MRR × t(m)]
- FRA value at time g (long): V = notional × (FRA_g − FRA_0) × t(m) ÷ [1 + L(h+m−g) × t(h+m−g)]
- Interest rate futures price: Price = 100 − (100 × futures rate)
- Futures basis point value: BPV = notional × 0.0001 × accrual period
- Bond futures price: QF0 = [FV(S0 + AI0) − AI_T − FV(coupons)] ÷ CF
- Swap fixed rate: r_fix = (1 − DF_N) ÷ Σ DF_t
- Value of a receive-fixed swap: V = (r_fix,0 − r_fix,t) × Σ DF (remaining) × notional
- Currency swap value: V = PV(leg received, with notional) − S_t × PV(leg paid, with notional), S_t converting the paid currency
- Equity swap value (receive equity, pay fixed): V = (S_t ÷ S(t−1)) × notional − PV(fixed-rate bond with notional)
Common traps
- Price isn't value: the forward price is fixed at initiation, while the contract's value starts at zero and then moves.
- A long FRA (pay fixed, receive floating) gains when rates rise; a long interest rate futures position gains when rates fall.
- A currency swap's value needs the current spot rate to convert one leg.
- An equity swap's equity return runs from the last reset date, not from inception.
How it's tested
Vignettes give spot prices, rates and dividends and ask for a no-arbitrage forward or futures price, a mark-to-market value, an FRA or swap rate, or the arbitrage that exploits a mispriced contract.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson