Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Financial institutions
Financial institutions
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Why banks and insurers need their own analysis, the regulation that shapes them, the CAMELS approach to banks and its limits, and the key measures for property and casualty and life and health insurers.
The rules
- What makes them different: financial institutions are systemically important (one failure can spread), highly leveraged, hold mostly financial assets often measured at fair value, depend on confidence (deposits can run), and are heavily regulated, with capital and liquidity rules that constrain growth and payouts.
- Regulation: the Basel Committee sets international bank standards; Basel III covers minimum capital against risk-weighted assets, liquidity and stable funding, with extra requirements for systemically important banks. The Financial Stability Board monitors systemic risk, the IAIS sets insurance standards and IOSCO securities standards. Rules are implemented nationally, so they differ across jurisdictions.
- Capital adequacy (C): Common Equity Tier 1 (common equity and retained earnings, less deductions such as goodwill) absorbs losses first; Additional Tier 1 (such as perpetual noncumulative preferred) and Tier 2 (such as subordinated debt) follow. Basel III minimums, before buffers, are 4.5% CET1, 6% Tier 1 and 8% total capital, each as a share of risk-weighted assets. Risk weights rise with credit risk (cash and high-quality government bonds near zero, loans higher). The leverage ratio uses unweighted exposure as a backstop.
- Asset quality (A): look at loan quality and the allowance for loan losses: nonperforming loans to total loans, the allowance relative to nonperforming loans and to total loans, provisions relative to net charge-offs, and net charge-offs to average loans. Provisions persistently below charge-offs draw down the allowance and flatter earnings. Also check concentrations (industry, region, borrower), the liquidity and fair value hierarchy level of securities (Level 3 needs judgment) and off-balance-sheet exposures.
- Management (M): judge governance, risk management, internal controls, transparency, related-party dealings and board oversight. It's qualitative, so look for evidence in disclosures, restatements, regulatory actions and how past problems were handled.
- Earnings (E): high-quality bank earnings are sustainable and come mainly from net interest income and fees rather than trading gains. Check the net interest margin, the income mix, operating efficiency, and how much earnings rest on estimates (loan loss provisions, fair values of illiquid assets, impairments). Earnings lifted by reserve releases or Level 3 gains are lower quality.
- Liquidity (L): the liquidity coverage ratio compares high-quality liquid assets with net cash outflows over a 30-day stress period; the net stable funding ratio compares available stable funding with required stable funding. Both must be at least 100%. Also check the loan-to-deposit ratio, reliance on wholesale funding, deposit concentration and maturity mismatches.
- Sensitivity to market risk (S): how earnings and capital respond to interest rates, exchange rates and equity and commodity prices. Look at repricing gaps between assets and liabilities, disclosed effects of rate shocks on net interest income and the economic value of equity, and value at risk on trading positions.
- Beyond CAMELS: it doesn't fully capture government support (implicit backing of systemically important banks), the bank's mission and culture, competitive position, diversification, off-balance-sheet items, segment and currency exposures, ESG risks, or the macroeconomic and regulatory environment. Read Basel III disclosures and stated risk factors too.
- Property and casualty insurers: short policies, uncertain and possibly catastrophic claims, and cyclical pricing. Key measures: the loss and loss adjustment expense ratio, the underwriting expense ratio, the combined ratio (under 100% means an underwriting profit), dividends to policyholders, and the adequacy of loss reserves (watch how past reserves develop). Investment income on premiums held can make an insurer profitable despite a combined ratio above 100%.
- Life and health insurers: long-duration policies make investment returns, interest rates and asset-liability matching central, and mortality and morbidity assumptions drive reserves. Key measures: benefits paid, and commissions plus expenses, each relative to net premiums written plus deposits; investment return; diversification of products and investments; liquidity (policy surrenders); and capital adequacy. For both kinds of insurer, reserve and investment valuation estimates drive earnings quality.
Formulas
- CET1 ratio: Common Equity Tier 1 capital ÷ risk-weighted assets
- Tier 1 capital ratio: (CET1 + Additional Tier 1) ÷ risk-weighted assets
- Total capital ratio: (Tier 1 + Tier 2) ÷ risk-weighted assets
- Leverage ratio: Tier 1 capital ÷ total unweighted exposure
- Liquidity coverage ratio: High-quality liquid assets ÷ net cash outflows over a 30-day stress period (at least 100%)
- Net stable funding ratio: Available stable funding ÷ required stable funding (at least 100%)
- Net interest margin: Net interest income ÷ average interest-earning assets
- Loan-to-deposit ratio: Total loans ÷ total deposits
- Loss and loss adjustment expense ratio: (Loss expense + loss adjustment expense) ÷ net premiums earned
- Underwriting expense ratio: Underwriting expenses ÷ net premiums written
- Combined ratio: Loss and LAE ratio + underwriting expense ratio
- Combined ratio after dividends: Combined ratio + dividends to policyholders ÷ net premiums earned
- Life insurer benefits ratio: Total benefits paid ÷ (net premiums written + deposits)
- Life insurer expense ratio: (Commissions + expenses) ÷ (net premiums written + deposits)
- Total investment return: Total investment income ÷ invested assets
Common traps
- A combined ratio under 100% is an underwriting profit; above 100% an insurer can still earn money from investment income.
- Capital ratios divide by risk-weighted assets; the leverage ratio deliberately doesn't.
- Provisions below net charge-offs shrink the allowance and lift current earnings at the expense of later ones.
- Trading gains and reserve releases boost bank earnings but persist less than net interest income and fees.
How it's tested
Item sets give a bank's or insurer's statements and regulatory disclosures; you compute capital, liquidity, asset quality or insurance ratios, judge which CAMELS component is weakest, or compare two institutions' risk and earnings quality.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson