Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Exchange-traded funds
Exchange-traded funds
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
How ETFs work and are used: creation and redemption by authorized participants, secondary market trading, tracking error, bid–ask spreads, premiums and discounts to NAV, the costs and risks of owning ETFs, and their uses in portfolios.
The rules
- Creation and redemption: only authorized participants (APs) deal directly with the fund, exchanging a basket of securities (or cash) for large blocks of ETF shares (creation units), and back again. When the ETF trades above NAV, APs buy the basket, create shares and sell them; below NAV, they buy shares and redeem them. This arbitrage keeps the price close to NAV.
- Tax efficiency and cost sharing: in-kind redemptions let the fund hand out low-cost-basis securities without selling them, so fewer capital gains are distributed. The costs of creating and redeeming fall on the APs, shielding long-term holders from trading costs caused by others.
- Secondary market: most investors buy and sell on an exchange, and most trading is between investors with no creation or redemption at all. Investors can trade throughout the day, use limit orders and settle like stocks.
- Tracking error sources: fees and expenses, representative sampling or optimization instead of holding every index security, use of derivatives, index changes and the costs of turnover, regulatory and tax limits (such as diversification rules), different timing of prices or exchange rates, cash drag, and securities lending income (which offsets costs). Tracking difference is the return gap over a period; tracking error is the annualized standard deviation of those gaps.
- Bid–ask spreads are set by market makers and reflect creation and redemption fees and other trading costs, the spreads on the underlying securities, the risk of carrying a position until it can be hedged or closed, and a normal profit, less a discount for the chance of matching buyers and sellers in the ETF itself. Heavily traded ETFs on liquid assets have the tightest spreads.
- Premiums and discounts appear when NAV is stale (foreign markets closed during trading hours, illiquid bonds priced with a lag), when the underlying is hard to trade, or in market stress. In those cases the ETF's price can be a better gauge of fair value than its NAV.
- Costs of ownership: the expense ratio (management fee), trading costs (commissions, the bid–ask spread, premiums or discounts), tracking error and taxes. Over short holding periods trading costs dominate; over long ones the expense ratio does.
- Risks: counterparty risk in swap-based (synthetic) ETFs, in ETNs (which are unsecured debt of the issuer) and from securities lending; fund closures; settlement risk; trading halts and price gaps in stressed markets; and expectation-related risk, such as leveraged and inverse ETFs that reset daily and drift away from the stated multiple of the index over longer periods.
- Portfolio uses: efficient portfolio management (putting idle cash to work, managing liquidity and redemptions, rebalancing, completion and transition management), core and tactical asset class exposure, factor (smart beta) and thematic exposure, active strategies, and risk management such as hedging and overlays.
Formulas
- Premium or discount to NAV: (ETF price − NAV) ÷ NAV
- Tracking difference: ETF return − index return
- Tracking error: Annualized standard deviation of tracking differences
- Round-trip trading cost: 2 × (one-way commission + ½ × bid–ask spread)
- Total holding period cost: Round-trip trading cost + expense ratio × holding period in years
- Bid–ask spread bound: Spread ≤ creation/redemption and trading costs + underlying spreads + risk premium for carrying the position + market maker's profit − discount for offsetting trades
Common traps
- Most ETF trading is investor to investor; it doesn't involve creations or redemptions.
- A premium on an international or bond ETF may reflect a stale NAV, not mispricing.
- Leveraged and inverse ETFs reset daily, so over longer periods they don't deliver the stated multiple of the index return.
- For short holding periods, trading costs matter more than the expense ratio.
How it's tested
Vignettes ask how creation and redemption close a premium, what causes tracking error or a wide spread, the total cost of holding an ETF, or which ETF use fits a portfolio need.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson