Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Equity valuation process
Equity valuation process
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
What valuation is for and how an analyst does it: intrinsic value and why prices diverge from it, the definitions of value, going-concern versus liquidation value, the valuation process, absolute versus relative models, sum-of-the-parts and how to pick a model.
The rules
- Intrinsic value is the value a complete understanding of the asset's characteristics would give. An analyst's estimate minus the price has two parts: true mispricing (actual intrinsic value minus price) and estimation error (the analyst's estimate minus actual intrinsic value). A gap may be the analyst's mistake, not the market's.
- Going concern versus liquidation: a going-concern value assumes the company keeps operating for the foreseeable future. A liquidation value is what it would bring if dissolved and its assets sold separately, in an orderly or a forced sale. For a business earning poor returns, liquidation value can exceed going-concern value.
- Definitions of value: fair market value is the price between a willing, informed buyer and seller, neither under pressure to deal. Fair value (financial reporting) is the price to sell an asset or transfer a liability between market participants in an orderly transaction. Investment value is the value to one particular buyer, including its synergies. For picking public stocks, intrinsic value is the relevant one.
- Uses of valuation: stock selection, reading the expectations built into a price, evaluating corporate events (mergers, divestitures, spin-offs, buyouts, recapitalizations), fairness opinions, planning and consulting, communication with analysts and shareholders, valuing private businesses and valuing share-based pay.
- The process: (1) understand the business, (2) forecast its performance, (3) select a model, (4) convert the forecasts into a value, (5) apply the conclusion. Forecasts can run top-down (economy, then industry, then company) or bottom-up.
- Industry and competitive analysis asks: how attractive is the industry for long-run profits (Porter's five forces)? What is the company's competitive position? Which strategy does it follow (cost leadership, differentiation or focus)? How well is it executing that strategy, judged against its past results?
- Absolute valuation estimates intrinsic value from fundamentals: present value models (dividends, free cash flow, residual income) and asset-based models. Relative valuation prices a stock against similar assets using multiples (the method of comparables); it can only say a stock is cheap or dear relative to its peers.
- Sum-of-the-parts: value each business segment separately, often with different methods or multiples, and add them. A conglomerate discount is a market value below that sum. Explanations: inefficient internal capital allocation, weaker companies choosing to diversify (endogenous factors), and research measurement errors that make the discount illusory. A breakup or spin-off can unlock the gap.
- Choosing a model: it should fit the company's characteristics (dividend record, asset base, growth stage), suit the quantity and quality of data available, and match the purpose and perspective of the valuation, such as a minority or a control view.
Formulas
- Perceived mispricing: Analyst's value − price = (true intrinsic value − price) + (analyst's value − true intrinsic value)
- Sum-of-the-parts value: Σ values of each segment, valued separately
Common traps
- A gap between your estimate and the price isn't proof of mispricing; part of it may be your own estimation error.
- Fair value for financial reporting isn't fair market value or investment value; only investment value includes one buyer's synergies.
- A stock that's cheap on relative valuation can still be overvalued in absolute terms if its whole peer group is overpriced.
- Don't assume going concern for a failing firm: when liquidation value is higher, it's the relevant value.
How it's tested
Vignettes ask which definition of value or which model fits a stated purpose and company, how to interpret a gap between estimate and price, and how sum-of-the-parts and conglomerate discounts apply.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson