Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Employee compensation
Employee compensation
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Accounting for and analyzing share-based pay and post-employment benefits (defined contribution and defined benefit plans, retiree health care): how they hit each statement under IFRS and US GAAP, and how to model them and adjust for them in valuation.
The rules
- Types of pay: short-term pay (salary, bonuses, benefits) is expensed as earned. Share-based pay aligns employees with shareholders but dilutes them, and options can encourage excessive risk-taking. Post-employment benefits include defined contribution (DC) plans, where the employer's cost is its agreed contribution and employees bear the investment risk, and defined benefit (DB) plans and retiree health care (other post-employment benefits), where the employer promises future benefits and bears the risk.
- Equity-settled share-based pay is measured at grant-date fair value and expensed over the service (vesting) period, with the credit to equity; it isn't remeasured later. Stock grants (restricted stock, performance shares) are valued at the share price at grant. Options are valued with an option-pricing model (Black–Scholes or binomial): higher expected volatility, a longer expected term or a higher risk-free rate raises the value and the expense, and a higher dividend yield lowers it.
- Cash-settled awards (stock appreciation rights settled in cash, phantom shares) are liabilities remeasured at fair value each period, so the expense swings with the share price; they don't dilute shareholders. In many tax systems the deduction follows the award's intrinsic value at exercise or vesting rather than the book expense, which creates deferred taxes and moves the effective tax rate.
- Modeling share-based pay: it's non-cash but a real cost, borne by shareholders through dilution. Forecast the expense (often as a percentage of revenue) as an operating cost, and forecast diluted shares (the treasury stock method for in-the-money options, plus expected new grants). Adding the expense back to cash flow while ignoring dilution overstates value per share.
- DB balance sheet: the funded status is the fair value of plan assets minus the benefit obligation (PBO under US GAAP, DBO under IFRS), which is the present value of benefits earned to date, including expected future pay increases. A deficit is a net pension liability; a surplus is an asset, capped at the economic benefit available (the asset ceiling) under IFRS.
- Rolling the plan forward: the obligation rises with current service cost, interest cost, past service cost and actuarial losses, and falls with benefits paid and actuarial gains. Plan assets rise with the actual return and employer contributions and fall with benefits paid. Paying benefits reduces both sides and leaves the funded status unchanged.
- IFRS pension cost: service cost (current plus past service cost, recognized at once) and net interest (discount rate × beginning net DB liability or asset) go to profit or loss. Remeasurements (actuarial gains and losses, the actual return on plan assets minus the amount in net interest, and changes in the asset ceiling effect) go to OCI and are never recycled. There's no expected-return assumption: in profit or loss, plan assets effectively earn the discount rate.
- US GAAP pension expense: current service cost + interest cost (discount rate × beginning PBO) − expected return on plan assets + amortization of past service cost + amortization of actuarial losses (or − gains). Past service cost, actuarial gains and losses, and the difference between the actual and expected return on plan assets first go to OCI and are then amortized into expense; actuarial gains and losses are amortized only beyond the corridor (10% of the greater of beginning PBO and beginning plan assets). Only service cost sits in operating income; the other components are reported outside it.
- Assumptions: a higher discount rate lowers the obligation and usually the service cost. A higher rate of compensation increase raises the obligation, service cost and interest cost. Longer life expectancy raises the obligation. A higher expected return on assets lowers US GAAP expense but doesn't affect IFRS expense or the obligation. For retiree health care, a higher health care cost trend rate, or a slower fall to the ultimate rate, raises the obligation and the expense.
- Analyst adjustments: treat a net pension deficit as debt and a surplus as an asset (after tax where relevant). For a cleaner income statement, keep only service cost in operating expense, reclassify interest cost as interest expense, and treat the return on plan assets as non-operating, using the actual return to strip out smoothing. If employer contributions exceed total periodic pension cost, the excess is like repaying debt, so move it (after tax) from operating to financing cash flow; a shortfall is like borrowing.
- Valuation and forecasting: subtract the after-tax pension deficit and other post-employment obligations when moving from enterprise value to equity value, and count a surplus only to the extent the company can benefit from it. Forecast service cost as an operating cost and cash contributions separately from expense. To compare peers, adjust for different discount rates and other assumptions, and for IFRS versus US GAAP presentation.
Formulas
- Funded status: Fair value of plan assets − benefit obligation
- Ending obligation: Beginning obligation + current service cost + interest cost + past service cost + actuarial losses − actuarial gains − benefits paid
- Ending plan assets: Beginning plan assets + actual return + employer contributions − benefits paid
- Interest cost: Discount rate × beginning obligation
- Total periodic pension cost: Service cost + interest cost + past service cost + actuarial losses − actuarial gains − actual return on plan assets = employer contributions − (ending funded status − beginning funded status)
- IFRS cost in profit or loss: Current service cost + past service cost + discount rate × beginning net DB liability (asset)
- US GAAP pension expense: Current service cost + interest cost − expected return on plan assets + amortization of past service cost + amortization of net actuarial loss (− gain)
- Expected return (US GAAP): Expected rate of return × beginning fair value of plan assets
- Corridor amortization (US GAAP): [Net actuarial loss − 10% × greater of beginning PBO or beginning plan assets] ÷ average remaining service period
- Cash flow reclassification: (Employer contributions − total periodic pension cost) × (1 − tax rate), moved from operating to financing
- Treasury stock method: New shares = options × (share price − exercise price) ÷ share price, if in the money
Common traps
- Under IFRS the expected-return assumption doesn't reach profit or loss; net interest uses the discount rate.
- IFRS remeasurements stay in OCI permanently; US GAAP amortizes actuarial losses beyond the corridor into expense.
- Equity-settled awards are fixed at grant-date fair value; only cash-settled awards are remeasured each period.
- Employer contributions aren't pension expense; the gap between them is a financing-like cash flow.
How it's tested
Vignettes give pension footnote data or share-based award terms; you compute funded status, periodic pension cost or expense under IFRS and US GAAP, judge the effect of an assumption change, make analyst adjustments, or model dilution and expense.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson