Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Dividends & share repurchases
Dividends & share repurchases
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Forms of payout and their effects, theories of dividend policy, signaling, clienteles, taxes and agency costs, payout policies, share repurchase methods and their effect on EPS and book value, and how to judge whether a dividend is safe.
The rules
- Forms of dividend: a regular cash dividend lowers cash and equity, raising leverage and lowering liquidity; an extra (special) dividend is a one-off that shouldn't be extrapolated; a liquidating dividend returns capital, as when a business is sold or wound down. Stock dividends and stock splits add shares and cut price and EPS in proportion, leaving shareholder wealth, total equity and leverage unchanged; a reverse split raises the price per share.
- Theories: Miller–Modigliani irrelevance: with no taxes, transaction costs or information gaps and a fixed investment policy, investors create “homemade dividends” by selling shares or reinvesting, so payout policy doesn't affect value. Bird-in-the-hand: investors value certain dividends above uncertain capital gains, so a higher payout lowers the cost of equity; MM answer that risk comes from the company's cash flows, not its payout. Tax argument: where dividends are taxed more heavily than capital gains, or gains can be deferred, a low payout adds value for taxable investors.
- Clientele effect: investors differ in tax status, need for current income and legal or institutional limits (some may hold only dividend payers), so companies attract clienteles that suit their policy and changing it can drive holders away. Taxes also show in the ex-dividend price drop, which equals the dividend only when dividends and capital gains are taxed alike.
- Signaling: managers know more than investors, and dividends are costly to cut, so initiations and increases signal confidence in future earnings while cuts and omissions signal trouble. Exceptions: a cut to fund strong investment opportunities can be read positively, and an increase by a firm with no growth options can signal it has nothing better to do with the cash. Signals matter more where information is scarce.
- Agency costs and practical factors: paying out free cash flow limits managers' empire-building and overinvestment, most usefully where good projects are scarce; large payouts can also transfer wealth from bondholders, which is why covenants restrict dividends. In practice, policy also depends on investment opportunities, expected earnings volatility, the value of financial flexibility, taxes, flotation costs of new equity (which make retained earnings cheaper) and legal and contractual limits such as capital impairment rules and covenants.
- Tax systems: under double taxation, earnings are taxed at the corporate rate and dividends again at the investor's rate. Under dividend imputation, shareholders get credit for the corporate tax paid, so the effective rate equals the shareholder's marginal tax rate. Under a split-rate system, distributed earnings bear a lower corporate rate than retained earnings and are then taxed at the investor's dividend rate.
- Payout policies: a stable dividend policy ties dividends to long-run sustainable earnings and moves gradually toward a target payout ratio, so dividends are smoother than earnings. A constant payout ratio policy pays a fixed share of each year's earnings, so dividends rise and fall with earnings. A residual policy pays whatever is left after funding the equity part of the capital budget. Trends: fewer companies pay cash dividends than in past decades in the US and other developed markets, and share repurchases have grown in importance worldwide.
- Repurchase methods: open market purchases are the most common, cheapest and most flexible, with no obligation to finish. A fixed-price tender offer buys a set number of shares at a set price, usually a premium, quickly. In a Dutch auction, holders tender within a price range and the company pays the lowest price that fills its target to everyone tendering at or below it. A direct negotiation buys from a specific large holder, sometimes at a premium that transfers value from the remaining shareholders.
- Effect on EPS and book value: a buyback funded with surplus cash raises EPS if the after-tax return given up on the cash is below the earnings yield (EPS ÷ price) of the shares bought; a debt-funded buyback raises EPS if the after-tax cost of debt is below the earnings yield. Buying back above book value per share lowers BVPS; below it raises BVPS. EPS accretion isn't value creation: buying at fair value leaves wealth unchanged, and overpaying hurts the holders who stay.
- Dividends vs buybacks: in perfect markets, equal-sized dividends and buybacks leave shareholders equally wealthy. Buybacks offer flexibility with no implied commitment, can signal that shares are undervalued, offset dilution from employee options, move leverage toward a target and may be taxed more lightly; regular dividends signal a lasting commitment.
- Dividend safety: watch for a high payout ratio, weak coverage by net income or FCFE, rising leverage to fund the payout, a dividend yield far above peers (the market may expect a cut), dividend growth running ahead of earnings growth, and declining or volatile earnings. An FCFE coverage ratio below 1 means paying out more than the company generates.
Formulas
- Ex-dividend price drop with taxes: Price drop = dividend × (1 − dividend tax rate) ÷ (1 − capital gains tax rate)
- Double taxation effective rate: Corporate rate + (1 − corporate rate) × individual dividend rate
- Split-rate effective rate: Corporate rate on distributed earnings + (1 − that rate) × individual dividend rate
- Imputation effective rate: Shareholder's marginal tax rate
- Target payout adjustment: Expected dividend increase = (expected EPS × target payout ratio − last dividend) × adjustment factor; adjustment factor = 1 ÷ years to reach target
- Constant payout dividend: Payout ratio × EPS
- Residual dividend: Earnings − capital budget × equity share of target capital structure, if positive
- Shares repurchased: Amount spent ÷ repurchase price per share
- EPS after a buyback: (Net income − after-tax interest paid on new debt or forgone on cash used) ÷ (shares − shares repurchased)
- Earnings yield: EPS ÷ share price
- BVPS after a buyback: (Book equity − amount spent) ÷ (shares − shares repurchased)
- Dividend coverage: Net income ÷ dividends
- FCFE coverage: FCFE ÷ (dividends + share repurchases)
Common traps
- Compare the earnings yield with the after-tax cost of debt, or the after-tax return on cash, not with a pre-tax rate or the cost of equity.
- Under imputation the effective rate is the shareholder's marginal rate, not the corporate rate.
- Stock dividends and splits change the share count and price, not wealth or total equity.
- A buyback above book value per share lowers BVPS even when it raises EPS.
How it's tested
Vignettes describe a company's payout decision; you compute EPS or BVPS after a buyback, an effective tax rate, a dividend under a target payout model, or coverage ratios, and interpret the signal or the theory that fits.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson