Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Corporate restructuring
Corporate restructuring
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Why companies buy, combine, sell, spin off and restructure; how to evaluate a proposed restructuring, value the businesses involved with comparables, precedent deals, DCF or sum of the parts, and measure the effect on EPS, leverage and the cost of capital.
The rules
- Investment actions: an equity investment (a minority stake) gains exposure or a foothold, often ahead of a later acquisition; a joint venture shares control, costs and risk with a partner, useful in new markets, but brings disputes and exit problems; an acquisition buys control. Motivations include growth, cost and revenue synergies, access to technology or markets, undervalued targets and tax benefits.
- Divestment actions: a sale transfers a business to a buyer for cash or stock and may trigger tax on the gain. A spin-off distributes a subsidiary's shares to existing shareholders, creating a separate company; the parent usually receives no cash, though the spun-off company may pay it a distribution funded with new debt. Motivations: refocusing on core businesses, removing a conglomerate discount, raising cash, or exiting low-return or troubled lines.
- Restructuring actions: cost restructuring (closing sites, cutting staff, outsourcing or offshoring) aims to bring margins back toward peers and usually starts with one-off charges. Balance sheet restructuring changes the asset base or capital structure: sale-leasebacks, changes in dividends or buybacks, leveraged recapitalizations. A reorganization restructures liabilities under court protection in bankruptcy.
- Initial evaluation: ask what the action is; why the issuer is doing it and why now (strategy, activist pressure, industry change); whether it's material relative to the issuer's size; what the terms are (price, form of payment, financing, timeline, conditions such as regulatory approval); and what it will likely do to earnings, leverage and risk.
- Comparable company analysis: value the target from trading multiples of similar public companies (EV/EBITDA, P/E), then add a takeover premium to estimate an acquisition price. It's simple and market-based, but no two companies truly match and any market mispricing carries through.
- Premiums paid analysis: take the mean, median and range of the premiums paid in comparable deals, each measured over the target's unaffected price (usually a week before the announcement), and apply them to the target's unaffected price.
- Comparable transaction analysis: value the target from multiples paid in recent acquisitions of similar companies. These already include a control premium, so don't add another. Limits: few truly comparable deals, prices set in different market conditions, and prices that may reflect overpayment.
- DCF and sum of the parts: a DCF values the target from forecast free cash flows, including expected synergies, discounted at a rate reflecting the target's risk; it's the most flexible method but sensitive to assumptions, especially the terminal value. A sum-of-the-parts valuation adds each segment's value (from its own multiples or DCF) less net debt and unallocated corporate costs; a total above market value suggests a conglomerate discount that a sale or spin-off could unlock.
- EPS accretion or dilution: in an all-stock deal, EPS rises if the P/E paid for the target is below the acquirer's own P/E. In a deal paid with cash or new debt, EPS rises if the target's earnings yield at the purchase price exceeds the after-tax interest rate given up or paid. Accretion isn't value creation: value comes from synergies exceeding the premium paid.
- Leverage and cost of capital: pro forma net debt to EBITDA combines both companies' net debt and any cash paid for the deal over combined EBITDA, plus synergies only if credible. Debt-financed deals raise leverage and can lower credit ratings; sales for cash can reduce it. WACC shifts with the combined business risk (buying a riskier business raises it, selling one lowers it) and with the new capital structure.
- Evaluating investment actions: check strategic fit, whether synergies are realistic and when they arrive, integration risk, the premium against the value of synergies, and the financing effects. For joint ventures, check governance and exit terms; for minority stakes, the path to control or exit and the accounting (the equity method if there's significant influence).
- Evaluating divestments and restructurings: for a sale, compare after-tax proceeds with the value given up (lost EBITDA and cash flows) and see how proceeds are used (debt paydown, buybacks, reinvestment). For a spin-off, judge whether both companies are viable alone, how debt and costs are split, and whether the parent's multiple should rise. For cost and balance sheet restructurings, check whether savings last once one-off charges are past.
Formulas
- Takeover premium: (Deal price per share − unaffected share price) ÷ unaffected share price
- Shares issued in a stock deal: Purchase price ÷ acquirer share price
- Pro forma EPS (stock deal): (Acquirer net income + target net income) ÷ (acquirer shares + new shares issued)
- Pro forma EPS (cash or debt deal): (Acquirer net income + target net income − after-tax interest on new debt or forgone on cash used) ÷ acquirer shares
- Accretion test (stock deal): Accretive if P/E paid for the target < acquirer's P/E
- Accretion test (cash or debt deal): Accretive if target earnings ÷ purchase price > after-tax cost of financing
- Pro forma net debt to EBITDA: (Acquirer net debt + target net debt + cash paid for the target) ÷ (acquirer EBITDA + target EBITDA)
- Sum-of-the-parts equity value: Sum of segment values − net debt − value of unallocated corporate costs
- Acquirer's gain: Value of synergies − premium paid
Common traps
- Comparable transaction multiples already contain a control premium; adding a takeover premium counts it twice.
- EPS accretion doesn't mean a deal creates value; paying a premium above the synergies destroys value even if EPS rises.
- A spin-off usually brings the parent no cash; a sale does.
- Pro forma leverage must include the target's existing debt as well as the cash or new debt used to pay for it.
How it's tested
Vignettes describe a proposed acquisition, sale, spin-off or restructuring; you identify its type and motive, value the target with comparables, precedent deals or sum of the parts, and compute pro forma EPS, net debt to EBITDA or the takeover premium.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson