Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Commodities
Commodities
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Commodity sectors and their life cycles, why commodities are valued differently from stocks and bonds, futures market participants, contango and backwardation, theories of futures returns, the components of a futures position's return, commodity swaps and how index design affects returns.
The rules
- Sectors: energy (crude oil, refined products, natural gas; driven by economic activity, geopolitics and storage), grains (weather, planting and harvest seasons), industrial metals (construction and manufacturing demand, long lead times for new mines), livestock (feed costs, breeding cycles, disease), precious metals (monetary and safe-haven demand plus industrial and jewelry use) and softs such as coffee, cocoa, sugar and cotton (weather in growing regions).
- Life cycles: supply is often fixed in the short run by planting, breeding, drilling or mining lead times, so prices react sharply to demand shocks and weather. Storability matters: metals store easily, livestock and many softs don't, and natural gas is costly to store, giving strong seasonal price patterns.
- Valuation: commodities produce no cash flows (no earnings, dividends or coupons), so they can't be valued by discounting cash flows. Prices come from expected supply and demand, and futures prices reflect the spot price, financing, storage costs and convenience yield.
- Participants: hedgers (producers usually short futures, consumers long), trading firms and merchants, speculators (including managed futures funds and index investors), arbitrageurs who trade physical goods against futures using storage, plus exchanges, analysts and regulators.
- Contango means futures prices are above spot (an upward-sloping curve), typical when inventories are ample. Backwardation means futures are below spot, typical when supply is tight and the convenience yield (the benefit of holding the physical good) is high.
- Theories of futures returns: insurance theory (Keynes): producers hedge by selling futures, pushing futures prices below expected spot prices (normal backwardation), so long speculators earn a risk premium. Hedging pressure hypothesis: producers and consumers both hedge, and whichever side dominates produces backwardation or contango. Theory of storage: the gap between futures and spot reflects storage costs minus convenience yield.
- Total return on a fully collateralized futures position = price return (the change in futures prices) + roll return (from replacing expiring contracts with later ones) + collateral return (interest on the collateral). An index also earns a rebalance return.
- Roll return is positive in backwardation (sell the expiring contract at a higher price, buy the next one cheaper) and negative in contango. It's only one part of total return, so contango alone doesn't mean a futures position will lose money.
- Commodity swaps: a total return swap pays the commodity index's return in exchange for a financing payment; an excess return swap exchanges payments based on the index's change relative to a benchmark or fixed level (the long receives when the index ends above it and pays when it ends below); a basis swap exchanges payments tied to two related commodity prices (such as a less liquid commodity against a liquid benchmark); variance and volatility swaps pay realized variance or volatility against a fixed strike.
- Index construction changes returns: the weighting method (production value, liquidity, equal or capped weights), the roll method (front-month or deferred contracts), the rebalancing frequency and which commodities are included. A production-weighted index is dominated by energy.
Formulas
- Futures price (approx.): Futures price ≈ spot price × (1 + r) + storage costs − convenience yield
- Total return: Total return = price return + roll return + collateral return (+ rebalance return for an index)
- Price return: (Current futures price − previous futures price) ÷ previous futures price
- Roll return: (Near-term contract price − farther-term contract price) ÷ near-term contract price × % of the position rolled
- Collateral return: Interest earned on the collateral, at the risk-free rate
Common traps
- Roll return is negative in contango and positive in backwardation, not the reverse.
- Contango or backwardation describes the shape of the curve; it doesn't forecast whether spot prices will rise or fall.
- Total return includes interest on the collateral; leaving it out understates the return.
- A higher convenience yield lowers futures prices relative to spot.
How it's tested
Vignettes give futures curves and returns and ask for the price, roll and collateral returns, which theory explains a curve, or which swap or index design delivers a stated exposure.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson