Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Code & Standards I–III
Code & Standards I–III
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
The Code of Ethics (integrity, clients and the profession before self, reasonable care and independent judgment, professionalism, market integrity, competence) and how CFA Institute enforces it, then Standards I (Professionalism), II (Integrity of Capital Markets) and III (Duties to Clients) with every sub-standard, applied the way Level II vignettes apply them.
The rules
- Professional Conduct Program (PCP): it enforces the Code and Standards. Members and candidates file an annual Professional Conduct Statement disclosing complaints, litigation and investigations. An inquiry can start from that statement, a written complaint, public reports such as news stories, an exam proctor's report, or CFA Institute's own review of exam data and social media. Staff can close it with no action, issue a cautionary letter, or propose a sanction; if the person rejects the proposed sanction, the matter goes to a hearing panel of Disciplinary Review Committee members, and a DRC panel also reviews cases where the person accepts. Member sanctions are public censure, suspension of membership and use of the CFA designation, and revocation of membership and the right to use the designation; candidates can be suspended or barred from the program.
- I(A) Knowledge of the Law: understand the laws, rules and regulations that govern your work and follow the stricter of them and the Code and Standards. Don't knowingly take part in or assist a violation. If you suspect one, raise it with a supervisor or compliance first; if it continues, dissociate (step away from the work, and in extreme cases leave the firm). The Code doesn't require reporting to regulators, though the law may and it can be prudent; staying silent while staying involved can amount to participation.
- I(B) Independence and Objectivity: don't offer, solicit or accept gifts, benefits or compensation that could reasonably be expected to compromise your own or another's independence. Modest gifts and entertainment are fine. Gifts from clients are less of a threat (clients already pay for the service) but should be disclosed to the employer, before accepting if possible. Issuer-paid research is allowed if the fee is flat, agreed in advance, not tied to the conclusions and disclosed. Pay your own travel to company visits where possible, and resist pressure from issuers, investment banking colleagues or large clients.
- I(C) Misrepresentation: no false or misleading statements or omissions about yourself, your firm, your services, performance or investments. Don't guarantee returns on investments that carry risk (describing a guarantee built into a product's structure is fine). Cite others' work: plagiarism is a violation. You may use factual data from recognized financial and statistical services without citation, and research or models developed by colleagues in your own firm. Don't present third-party or outsourced work as your own.
- I(D) Misconduct: no dishonesty, fraud or deceit in professional conduct, and no act that reflects badly on your professional reputation, integrity or competence. Purely personal matters usually aren't covered (a personal bankruptcy with no fraud), but acts that reflect on honesty or professional competence, such as fraud or being impaired at work, are. I(E) Competence: act with and keep up the competence your work needs, for example before advising on a product or market that is new to you.
- II(A) Material Nonpublic Information: don't act, or cause others to act, on information that is material (likely to move the price, or a reasonable investor would want it; weigh its specificity and the reliability of the source) and nonpublic (not yet disseminated to the market as a whole; telling a few analysts doesn't make it public). Encourage the issuer to make it public. The mosaic theory allows a material conclusion drawn from public information plus nonmaterial nonpublic pieces. Firms prevent breaches with firewalls (compliance control of communication between departments, physical separation, review of employee and proprietary trading), watch lists and restricted lists.
- II(B) Market Manipulation: don't distort prices or artificially inflate trading volume with intent to mislead market participants. Information-based manipulation spreads false or misleading information (rumors, pump-and-dump). Transaction-based manipulation uses trades that give a false impression of price or volume, or a dominant position used to move a security or its derivatives. Legitimate strategies (arbitrage, tax-motivated trades, liquidity provision) aren't manipulation; intent to mislead is the test.
- III(A) Loyalty, Prudence, and Care: act for clients' benefit and put their interests before your employer's and your own, with the care of a prudent person. Identify the actual client: for a pension plan, the participants and beneficiaries, not the sponsor; for a fund, manage to its stated mandate. Client brokerage (soft dollars) belongs to the client: use it only for research that helps the investment decision process, and seek best execution. Vote proxies in clients' interest; a cost-benefit view can justify not voting every proxy.
- III(B) Fair Dealing: treat all clients fairly, which doesn't mean identically, when disseminating recommendations and taking action. Communicate recommendation changes to affected clients at the same time, and allocate block trades and oversubscribed IPOs pro rata to every account for which they're suitable, never favoring your own, family or favored accounts. Premium service levels are fine if disclosed and open to all who pay for them. Good practice: limit who knows of a change before release, shorten the time to release, and keep written trade allocation procedures.
- III(C) Suitability: in an advisory relationship, ask about the client's experience, return and risk objectives and constraints before advising; record them in a written IPS and review it at least annually and when circumstances change; judge each investment by its effect on the whole portfolio. When managing a fund to a mandate, keep to its stated objectives and constraints. If a client asks for an unsuitable trade on their own initiative, explain the mismatch and document it; if it would materially change the portfolio's risk, discuss updating the IPS.
- III(D) Performance Presentation: make reasonable efforts to keep performance fair, accurate and complete: include terminated accounts, label simulated or back-tested results, and say whether returns are gross or net of fees; a brief presentation is fine if fuller detail is offered. Complying with GIPS is the recommended route. III(E) Preservation of Confidentiality: keep information about current, former and prospective clients confidential unless it concerns illegal activity by the client, the law requires disclosure, or the client allows it. Sharing information with the PCP is not a breach.
Common traps
- Local law that is looser than the Code doesn't lower the bar, and the Code never requires breaking the law: apply whichever is stricter.
- Information given to a select few (a private call with some analysts) is still nonpublic; the mosaic theory covers conclusions built only from public and nonmaterial pieces.
- For a pension plan, the client is the participants and beneficiaries, not the company that hired you.
- Fair dealing means fairly, not equally: tiered service is allowed if disclosed, but trading ahead of clients or leaving suitable accounts out of a hot issue isn't.
How it's tested
Vignettes describe an analyst's or manager's actions and ask whether a specific action violates a standard, which standard it breaches, or what the person should have done; several facts look suspicious but only some are violations.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson