Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Bonds with embedded options
Bonds with embedded options
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Valuing and analyzing callable, putable, extendible and capped or floored floating-rate bonds and convertibles: how option value, volatility and the yield curve affect price, option-adjusted spreads, effective and one-sided durations, key rate durations and effective convexity.
The rules
- Types: callable bonds (the issuer may redeem early), putable bonds (the holder may sell back), extendible bonds (the holder may extend maturity; worth the same as a longer bond putable at the original maturity), sinking fund bonds (scheduled retirement, often with call and delivery options), estate (survivor's) puts and contingent convertibles that turn into equity when a trigger, such as a bank's capital ratio falling, is hit.
- Value relationships: callable bond = straight bond − call option (held by the issuer); putable bond = straight bond + put option (held by the investor). In a calibrated tree, at each node where the option can be exercised, a callable's value is the lower of the computed value and the call price; a putable's is the higher of the computed value and the put price.
- Volatility and the curve: higher rate volatility raises any option's value, so callable bonds lose value and putable bonds gain; straight bonds are unaffected. Falling rates raise the call's value and cap a callable's price gain; rising rates raise the put's value and limit a putable's loss. A flatter or inverted curve (lower forward rates) makes a call worth more and a put worth less than an upward-sloping curve does.
- Option-adjusted spread (OAS): the constant spread added to every rate in the tree that makes the model value equal the market price. It removes the option's effect: option cost = Z-spread − OAS, positive for callables and negative for putables. Compare OAS with bonds of similar credit and liquidity: a higher OAS means a cheaper bond.
- OAS and volatility: for a given price, assuming higher volatility lowers a callable's model value, so a smaller spread is needed and the OAS falls; for a putable the OAS rises. A cheap-or-rich call based on OAS depends on the volatility assumed.
- Effective duration must be used for bonds with options: shift the benchmark curve up and down, revalue each in the tree. Callable and putable bonds have effective durations no greater than an otherwise identical straight bond's; a callable's shortens when rates fall, a putable's when rates rise.
- One-sided and key rate durations: a callable is less sensitive to falling rates than to rising rates, and a putable the reverse, so one-sided durations (for an up or a down shift only) capture the asymmetry. Key rate durations show where on the curve the sensitivity sits: near the call or put date when exercise is likely, near maturity when it isn't.
- Effective convexity: straight bonds have positive convexity. A callable has negative convexity when rates are low and the call is likely to be exercised. A putable has more positive convexity than a straight bond when rates are high and the put is likely to be exercised.
- Capped and floored floaters: a cap limits the coupon and benefits the issuer: capped floater = straight floater − cap. A floor sets a minimum coupon and benefits the holder: floored floater = straight floater + floor. In the tree, each period's coupon is set by the rate at the start of the period (subject to the cap or floor) and paid at its end.
- Convertible bonds: the holder can exchange the bond for shares at the conversion ratio. Its value is at least the higher of its straight value and its conversion value. It equals a straight bond + a call on the stock, minus any issuer call and plus any investor put. Arbitrage-free valuation needs a model of both rates and the share price, which is complex.
- Convertible risk and return: far below the conversion price (a busted convertible) it trades like a bond; deep in the money it trades like the stock; in between it's a hybrid. Compared with the stock, it gives up some upside (the conversion premium) for downside protection from the bond floor; compared with a straight bond, it offers upside at the cost of a lower yield. An issuer call can force conversion.
Formulas
- Callable bond: V_callable = V_straight − V_call
- Putable bond: V_putable = V_straight + V_put
- Callable node value: V = min{call price, 0.5 × [(V_up + C) + (V_down + C)] ÷ (1 + r)}
- Putable node value: V = max{put price, 0.5 × [(V_up + C) + (V_down + C)] ÷ (1 + r)}
- Option cost: Option cost (bp) = Z-spread − OAS
- Effective duration: ED = (PV− − PV+) ÷ (2 × ΔCurve × PV0)
- Effective convexity: EC = (PV− + PV+ − 2 × PV0) ÷ (ΔCurve^2 × PV0)
- Capped floater: V = straight floater − value of cap
- Floored floater: V = straight floater + value of floor
- Conversion price: Par value ÷ conversion ratio
- Conversion value: Share price × conversion ratio
- Market conversion price: Convertible price ÷ conversion ratio
- Market conversion premium per share: Market conversion price − share price
- Market conversion premium ratio: Premium per share ÷ share price
- Premium over straight value: (Convertible price ÷ straight value) − 1
- Minimum convertible value: max(straight value, conversion value)
- Convertible value: Straight bond + call on stock − issuer call + investor put
Common traps
- Use effective duration for bonds with options; modified duration assumes the cash flows don't change when rates do.
- For a putable bond the OAS is above the Z-spread, so the option cost is negative.
- Higher volatility lowers a callable's value, raises a putable's, and leaves a straight bond's unchanged.
- A cap benefits the issuer and a floor benefits the holder; don't reverse the signs.
How it's tested
Vignettes give a tree and ask for a callable, putable or capped floater value, an OAS-based judgment, effective duration or convexity, or convertible bond measures.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson