Study guides / CFA L2: CFA Program Level II / Arbitrage-free valuation
Arbitrage-free valuation
CFA L2: CFA Program Level II · quick review
Valuing bonds so that no arbitrage exists: discounting with spot or forward rates, building and calibrating a binomial interest rate tree, backward induction and pathwise valuation, Monte Carlo simulation, and the main term structure models.
The rules
- Arbitrage-free value: each cash flow is discounted at the spot rate for its date (or the chain of one-period forwards), so a bond is worth exactly the sum of its zero-coupon pieces. Otherwise dealers would strip or reconstitute it for a riskless profit. Arbitrage takes two forms: value additivity (the whole priced differently from the sum of its parts) and dominance (a riskless payoff priced away from its present value).
- Binomial interest rate tree: each node holds a one-period forward rate, and up and down moves are equally likely (risk-neutral probabilities of 0.5). Rates are lognormal: adjacent rates at the same date differ by a factor of e^(2σ), so rates stay positive and their absolute volatility rises with their level.
- Calibration: for a chosen volatility, set the rates at each date so the tree prices the on-the-run benchmark bonds exactly, solving one maturity at a time. A calibrated tree gives an option-free bond the same value as discounting with spot rates.
- Backward induction: start at maturity; at each earlier node, value = the average of (next-period value + coupon) across the up and down nodes, discounted at that node's own rate. Repeat back to today.
- Zero curve versus lattice: for an option-free bond the zero curve is enough, and volatility doesn't affect its value. A lattice is needed when cash flows depend on the path of future rates being above or below a level, as with embedded options.
- Pathwise valuation: list every possible path of rates through the tree, discount the cash flows along each path, and average the results. An n-year tree with annual steps has 2^(n−1) paths. The answer matches backward induction.
- Monte Carlo simulation generates many random rate paths and suits path-dependent cash flows, such as mortgage-backed securities whose prepayments depend on the rates seen along the way. A drift adjustment makes the paths reprice benchmark bonds, and mean reversion keeps rates realistic. More paths cut sampling error but can't fix a wrong model.
- Equilibrium models (Cox–Ingersoll–Ross, Vasicek) derive the term structure from a few parameters and assumptions about the economy; they may not match today's prices. Arbitrage-free models (Ho–Lee, Kalotay–Williams–Fabozzi) take today's curve as given and are calibrated to it, so they price benchmarks exactly.
- Model features: CIR and Vasicek are mean-reverting one-factor models; CIR's volatility rises with the rate level and keeps rates from going negative, while Vasicek's constant volatility allows negative rates. Ho–Lee has a time-varying drift and constant volatility, so rates can go negative; KWF models the log of the rate, so rates stay positive.
Formulas
- Arbitrage-free value: V = Σ CF_t ÷ (1 + S_t)^t
- Value using forwards: V = Σ CF_t ÷ [(1 + f0) × (1 + f1) × … × (1 + f(t−1))]
- Adjacent node rates: r_higher = r_lower × e^(2σ)
- Node value: V = 0.5 × [(V_up + C) + (V_down + C)] ÷ (1 + r_node)
- Vasicek: dr = a(b − r)dt + σ dz
- Cox–Ingersoll–Ross: dr = a(b − r)dt + σ√r dz
- Ho–Lee: dr = θ_t dt + σ dz
- Kalotay–Williams–Fabozzi: d ln(r) = θ_t dt + σ dz
Common traps
- Discount at each node's own one-period rate, not at the bond's yield to maturity.
- Tree probabilities are 0.5 risk-neutral probabilities, not forecasts of rate moves.
- Changing the volatility assumption doesn't change a calibrated tree's value for an option-free bond.
- Backward induction can't handle path-dependent cash flows; those need Monte Carlo.
How it's tested
Vignettes give a calibrated tree and ask for a node value or bond value, the arbitrage profit from a mispriced bond, or which method or term structure model suits a security.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson