Study guides / AUD: Auditing & Attestation / Substantive procedures
Substantive procedures
AUD: Auditing & Attestation · quick review
Substantive procedures (tests of details and substantive analytical procedures) detect material misstatements at the assertion level. Some are required in every audit, whatever the assessed risk.
The rules
- Always required: substantive procedures for each material class of transactions, balance and disclosure; agreeing the statements to the underlying records; and examining material journal entries and adjustments.
- Receivables confirmation is presumed unless the balance is immaterial, confirmation would be ineffective, or risk is low and other procedures address it. Document why if you don't confirm.
- Nonresponses to positive confirmations need alternative procedures, such as subsequent cash receipts, shipping documents and contracts. Negative confirmations alone require low risk, many small homogeneous balances, a very low expected exception rate, and no reason recipients would ignore them.
- Inventory: attend the count when inventory is material. Test counts both ways (records to floor for existence, floor to records for completeness) and test cutoff.
- Unrecorded liabilities: search payments and invoices after year end, and consider confirming vendors with zero or small balances.
Formulas
- Substantive analytical expectation difference: Recorded amount − Auditor's independent expectation (investigate if above the threshold)
Common traps
- Confirming large recorded payables tests existence, not completeness.
- Substantive procedures at an interim date need rollforward procedures covering the rest of the period.
- The more precise the expectation, the more reliable a substantive analytical procedure is. Loose, high-level ratios give weak evidence.
How it's tested
Choose the best procedure for an assertion and account (cash, receivables, inventory, payables, investments), and evaluate confirmation results. Expect option list simulations.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson