Study guides / AUD: Auditing & Attestation / Internal control
Internal control
AUD: Auditing & Attestation · quick review
Auditors must understand internal control (the five COSO components and relevant controls) in every audit, and must test operating effectiveness only when planning to rely on controls or when substantive procedures alone aren't enough.
The rules
- COSO components (CRAIM): Control environment, Risk assessment, control Activities, Information and communication, Monitoring activities, supported by 17 principles.
- Segregation of duties separates authorization, custody and recording. Custody plus recording is the classic incompatible pairing.
- Design and implementation are evaluated in every audit (inquiry plus observation, inspection or a walkthrough). Operating effectiveness needs tests over the period of reliance.
- Service organizations: a SOC 1 Type 1 covers design at a date, and a Type 2 adds operating effectiveness over a period. The user auditor must consider complementary user entity controls (CUECs) and any gap between the report period and year end.
- IT general controls (access, change management, operations) support the automated controls and reports the auditor relies on.
Common traps
- A walkthrough shows a control exists. It doesn't show the control worked all year.
- Inquiry alone is never enough to test operating effectiveness.
- Management override is a limitation of every control system, and collusion can defeat segregation of duties.
How it's tested
Identify weak segregation, choose tests of controls, evaluate SOC reports and classify deficiencies. Option list and document review simulations often use narratives and flowcharts.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson