Study guides / AUD: Auditing & Attestation / Ethics & independence
Ethics & independence
AUD: Auditing & Attestation · quick review
Independence is required for audits, reviews and examinations, but not for preparation engagements. The AICPA Code uses a conceptual framework (threats and safeguards), with specific prohibitions layered on top. SEC and PCAOB rules are stricter for issuer audits.
The rules
- Covered members include the engagement team, people who can influence the engagement, partners in the office where the lead partner works, and the firm. A direct or material indirect financial interest in an attest client impairs independence.
- Loans from a financial institution client are allowed only if made under normal terms: car loans secured by the car, loans fully secured by cash deposits, credit cards and overdrafts up to $10,000, and grandfathered home mortgages.
- Nonattest services impair independence if the member assumes a management responsibility, such as authorizing transactions, holding assets, or deciding which recommendations to adopt. For permitted services, management must oversee the work and accept responsibility, and the terms must be documented.
- Contingent fees are banned for audit and review clients, compilations used by third parties that don't disclose a lack of independence, examinations of prospective information, and original tax returns.
- Issuer audits (SOX §201): no bookkeeping, systems design, valuation, actuarial, internal audit outsourcing, management or HR functions, broker-dealer, legal or unrelated expert services. Other services, including most tax work, need audit committee pre-approval. The lead and concurring partners rotate every 5 years.
Common traps
- A preparation engagement doesn't require independence. A compilation lets you disclose a lack of independence. A review requires independence.
- A threat you can't reduce to an acceptable level with safeguards means declining or ending the engagement. Disclosure doesn't cure it.
- Firm policy and immediate family count: a spouse's direct financial interest is treated as the covered member's own.
How it's tested
Mostly remembering-level multiple choice: identify whether a loan, investment, fee or nonattest service impairs independence under the AICPA, SEC or PCAOB rules. Research simulations may ask for the relevant ET section.
Practise it
The full lesson, worked examples and practice questions are in Tickmark, where every answer choice is explained.
Open the full lesson